David brooks explained the difference really well. The bailout of wall st. Was a bailout of the entire financial system. If it didn't happen comapnies would not be able to borrow any money. Forget who it's from. If we don't bail out the big three we will all still be able to buy tons of different kinds of cars. (Can't send link from iPhone)
Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt
by fallentimes on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @06:01PM
(#370077)
Small businesses were affected by the financial crisis more than people realize. Businesses with long sales cycles (e.g. media companies, advertising companies) often use commercial paper to finance their short term recurring financial expenses (payroll expenses, rent, etc).
No bailout, no commercial paper, no paycheck.
As we save the companies that crippled the credit markets, we have no interest in spending a fraction of that same amount of money helping the companies most negatively effected by the condition of those same credit markets.
are you trying to tell me that gm is simply a victim of the credit crisis???
why would a bank loan them money now?? aren't we all about responsible lending now?? lending money to gm is the corporate equivalent of a subprime loan. we don't want banks making subprime loans anymore.
Yes. How do people buy cars? On credit. Harder to get credit means fewer people capable of buying cars. A bad economy means fewer people buying cars. GM et al, did not create the credit crisis. They did not create the bad economic conditions.
But we want them, and more importantly, all the people working in that industry to suffer? Honestly, I can't imagine how letting them fail won't cause more than 25 billion in economic damage.
You think giving them $25 billion is going to be the end of it? They'll just be out of cash again in 6 months, asking for another bailout.
Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt
by redrobot5050 on Thursday November 20, 2008 @03:49PM
(#370993)
GM did create part of the credit crisis. DiTech.com. Its primary business was the variable-rate (aka "teaser rate") ARMs and home equity re-financing. In short, GM put a sizable amount of cash into the sub-prime loan market, and got burned just like everyone else.
They build cars nobody wants anymore, credit or no credit.
GM is still #2 in sales worldwide.
Then they are even LESS deserving of a bailout, no?
Then why do they have a problem?
Financial wing GMAC got killed by subprime, the credit crunch, gas prices... all that on top of lagging sales. Sure, some of that perfect storm is their own fault. But, it's not as simple as "their cars suck" and "the workers make too much money".
If everyone pays for the things that are not their own fault, then the playing field is leveled. Then the things that are their own fault come into play, and those parties who were hit by the common problems AND their own problems will suffer more than those who didn't have their own problems (or had smaller self inflicted problems). Seems this is the way it should be.
As we save the companies that crippled the credit markets, we have no interest in spending a fraction of that same amount of money helping the companies most negatively effected by the condition of those same credit markets.
I'm sorry, but I don't see anyone buying a car from a manufacturer in bankruptcy. I think bankruptcy will be the end of the American auto manufacturers. The resulting damage will dwarf the 25 billion a bailout would cost.