News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Games Where The Only Winning Move Is Not To Play by malandrew on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @03:53PM (#3700074)
I'm wondering what the result would be if this actually did escalate/spiral out of control with everyone suing everyone for every patent they have in Silicon Valley.

Maybe the best way to bring about patent reform is to highlight the absurdity of the system by blowing the entire system up.

Every patent holding company should just literally clog the court system with this BS. The lawyers from both each side of a suit can even be aware of the fact that the other side has no intention of actually trying to win a case and is instead just asserting its patents and forcing the courts to deal with them.

When you file a patent lawsuit, are you required to claim damages or can you just claim nothing, but just file a suit that you want the judicial system to deliberate on. i.e. can you seek judgement without seeking damages?

Re:Games Where The Only Winning Move Is Not To Play by jpdoctor on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @04:18PM (#3700203)
> spiral out of control with everyone suing everyone for every patent they have in Silicon Valley.

That misses the real dynamic: Yahoo is suing because FB has money + they don't have as deep of a patent portfolio. (It's why Google shelled out a pile of dough for Nortel's portfolio.) The lawsuit wouldn't have happened if they had comparable portfolios; The lawsuits would then have ended in a draw.

Bullying/shakedown at its best. (I'm sure it's not personal to Scott Thompson, just business.)

Re:Games Where The Only Winning Move Is Not To Play by tomjen3 on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @04:47PM (#3700351)
Nah FB can drag this through the court system for years or even decades and then find some way to kill Yahoo in the meantime.

FB must have made a lot of improvements in online ads, which as far as I am aware, is what makes Yahoo money (side note, do Yahoo actually earn money?) so that would be an obvious place to attack. An alternative is to team up with Microsoft, who desperately needs some sort of social media strategy and have very very extensive patent portfolios.

Re:Games Where The Only Winning Move Is Not To Play by jpdoctor on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @05:02PM (#3700420)
> Nah FB can drag this through the court system for years or even decades and then find some way to kill Yahoo in the meantime.

It's a big distraction for FB. It's not a distraction for Y! (because obviously they don't have much business left in their business). So my guess is that FB settles to get it off their plate.

If FB instead takes the strategy you mention above and blows all that money, I'd love them to death for it. ("You wanna piece of me?! Come over here and let's rumble!" It would tell patent trolls that they are going to have to blow serious money in the future.)

Re:Games Where The Only Winning Move Is Not To Play by tomjen3 on Wednesday March 14, 2012 @12:07PM (#3703781)
Define distraction? You would need, say 10 full time lawyers on it, assume 200k/year on average, which would cost about 2 million a year.

Mark doesn't need to focus on the law suit, instead he can simply spawn of a process and subscribe to its signals (to borrow an OS metaphor).

Re:Games Where The Only Winning Move Is Not To Play by nextparadigms on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @04:16PM (#3700192)
I fear that if that happens, the best case scenario would be some kind of "compromise" between the major patent holders, because by then they'd still have a lot invested in them, and the overall situation would still be worse than it is now when web patents aren't enforced.