News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by antidaily on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @04:44PM (#369973)
I'd rather bailout GM and Ford, who are not just hurting because of bad business decisions but also because of the credit crunch and high gas prices then, say, Bear Stearns.
Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by fallentimes on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @05:17PM (#370008)
This might sound crass, but companies who knowingly and actively pay people to do nothing on a perpetual basis deserve to die:

http://www.detnews.com/2005/autosinsider/0510/17/A01-351179....

Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by dionidium on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @08:12PM (#370178)
We can probably all agree that's it's silly to require that workers play dress-up and come to a non-existent job every morning.

But, assuming that requirement were dropped, you haven't exactly explained why it was wrong of the workers to ask for a piece of the (extraordinarily high [0]) earnings the company enjoyed at that time, or why it was wrong of the company to pay it.

Am I wrong to assume that the company thought it to be the best terms they could negotiate at that time? What should the union have done? Accept less than they could negotiate for? What should the company have done? Insist on more favorable terms even if the cost of a protracted labor dispute were actually more expensive?

I keep hearing people refer to outcomes that appear to be the natural result of difficult negotiations in strictly moral terms. This seems silly. Help me understand why I'm wrong.

[0] http://www.mlive.com/business/index.ssf/2008/09/a_brief_hist...

Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday November 20, 2008 @03:34PM (#370974)
What should the union have done? Accept less than they could negotiate for?

Sometimes it makes sense to accept less than you can negotiate for: (a) you don't want to kill the goose laying the golden eggs and (b) that overly hard negotiation can mean you're walking around with an "Outsource Me" target on your back. Get what you want when you can get it, but remain aware of the consequences.

Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by fallentimes on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @08:41PM (#370204)
That's a strawman; I never said it was wrong to ask.

Anyways...

The company should have invested more of their marketing budget in R&D and produced quality cars. Empirically (consumer reports, Car & Driver, et al) U.S. cars have been subpar compared to their foreign counterparts for many years. Though some of my friends & family insist they're rapidly catching up nowadays. In the present, I don't know one way or the other.

In the States' current system, the company doesn't have any obligation to share high earnings with their employees. They have an obligation to deliver profits to shareholders - that's it. If the employees don't like it, they can get another job that pays them market wages or treats them better. In short, that's the best part & worst part of the system. Paying employees above market wages is not sustainable.

In the short term, companies can unfortunately deliver profits to their shareholders with shady tactics, breaking the law, gray area revenue recognition, poor employee treatment and "earnings management". In the long-term, that doesn't work and is stupid. And many times it's against the law.

It's not a coincidence that the companies that treat their employees the best outperform the market. [1]

[1] http://www.greatplacetowork.com/great/graphs.php

Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by dionidium on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @09:15PM (#370228)
"The company doesn't have any obligation to share high earnings with their employee. "

I never suggested that they do. In fact, I think I rather explicitly argued that they paid those wages because it was the best deal they could negotiate at the time. If they could have negotiated a better deal, they would have.

More generally, if I agree to do a certain amount of work for a certain pay, it does not imply that I deserve that pay (whatever that means). But surely it means that the person paying me thinks that wage (considering the alternatives) to be in their best interest.

"If they don't like it, they can get another job that pays them market wages or treats them better."

Or collectively negotiate better wages?

Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by fallentimes on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @10:44PM (#370294)
Right, but you asked why they didn't. If they collectively negotiate above market wages the company will die in the long term.
Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by Dilpil on Friday November 21, 2008 @12:45PM (#372130)
It's not a coincidence, indeed, it is a logical inevitability: it is far easier to treat your employees well if your company is successful.
Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by mbreese on Friday November 21, 2008 @03:13PM (#372279)
But it's also true that happy workers are more productive, healthier, less likely to quit, and thus will make the company more successful.
Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by antidaily on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @05:29PM (#370021)
Ok, but how about the hundreds of small businesses and suppliers that depend on the Big 3 for work?
Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by ars on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @07:02PM (#370115)
They'll be better off in the long run. Let GM, etc fail, and get rid of the crippling unions. Then come back with normal hiring practices and they'll buy from suppliers again.
Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by chaostheory on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @11:42PM (#370326)
forgot to mention this but most of the Big 3's parts aren't even American:

http://www.cato-at-liberty.org/2008/11/18/what-is-an-america...

Not to mention:

"Cars.com found only four cars and six light trucks with a domestic content (meaning US or Canadian) above 75%. That list includes the Toyota Tundra and Sienna and the Honda Odyssey. Other Honda’s have a 60-70% domestic content, barely missing the cut"

Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by ckinnan on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @07:47PM (#370161)
What about the hundreds of small businesses and startups that are paying the taxes to subsidize the Detroit Three's failure?
Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by fallentimes on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @05:51PM (#370053)
In short; they're in trouble. That's why you should never ever put all your eggs in one basket.

As I noted in this post:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=369994

my family has already been hurt by this. My Dad was laid off, my Grandpa was forced in to retirement. My other Grandpa lost his job. One of my Uncles who did supplies sales was laid off. Only one of the above actually worked at one of the US car companies - the rest were part of the supplies/small businesses.

Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by chaostheory on Wednesday November 19, 2008 @05:57PM (#370063)
smart businesses (especially small ones) change and adapt. if not they fail. why subsidize bad practices and decisions?
Re:Let Detroit Go Bankrupt by lutorm on Thursday November 20, 2008 @11:54AM (#370724)
The aim of government is not to support businesses but to support the citizenry. The relevant question is not whether businesses will be better off, it's whether people will be better off.