News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by sambeau on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @06:07AM (#3697718)
ARM is a brilliant (if not the poster-boy) example of why the UK government should be investing in new technology companies rather than car manufacturing and banking.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by gaius on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @07:51AM (#3697976)
I suppose you are too young to remember "picking winners", Harold Wilson, British Leyland, Red Robbo... Or more directly, Grundy and their NewBrain vs Acorn... Historically, government meddling in industry in the UK has been a disaster.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by calibraxis on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @08:39AM (#3698105)
The US government picked winners like Intel, saving the US semiconductor industry through protectionist policies. (http://www.forbes.com/2003/10/10/1010grovepinnacor.html) In fact, the US technology industry was developed through enormous subsidy, from transistors to the internet.

Economist Ha-Joon Chang discusses that's how powerful nations develop. The entrepreneurial Japanese government's first forays into the auto industry were failures, but of course they kept at it, learning from failure. That's the nature of investment, as any HN reader should know.

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by arethuza on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @09:50AM (#3698380)
My experience of government "investment" (both UK and EU) in the technology sector is that is has been the most frightful waste of money imaginable.

It's not down to lack of money - but the way it has been spent.

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by astrodust on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @10:50AM (#3698665)
You have to remember how many failures it takes to have a big success. For every Intel there's a wasteland of shoulda-been companies that are dead and forgotten, with billions invested having gone up in smoke.

Of course, when it's private venture capital that's behind this, people don't seem to complain as much.

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by arethuza on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @11:06AM (#3698743)
Honestly, I've been in a couple of startups (including one that got a lot of funding from VCs and going public) and I've never seen anything like the inefficiency that was normal in the public sector projects that I worked on.

Not that I'm against public funding of research - I'm absolutely not. But my experiences of public sector research funding on "large" projects completely put me off working in that sector (so much so that I left academia to co-found a start-up).

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by easp on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @01:47PM (#3699515)
Publicly funded projects are such an inefficient mess, in part, because of all the shit that is done to make sure that tax dollars aren't "wasted."
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by arethuza on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @03:17PM (#3699896)
That was probably the single biggest issue, although there were others, there was a huge administrative overhead on all of the projects that it made it difficult to spot where any actual research was being done.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by EvilLook on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @03:13PM (#3699883)
True that.

I've worked on publicly funded projects and in the private sector. The publicly funded projects were the worst for pointless reporting, accounting, and paperwork.

In the private sector, the boss pops his head in and asks what I've done to day and what I'll finish by the end of the week, and we adjust goals. It takes about 5 minutes a week to do this.

When I was working on a publicly funded project, there was a report to be filed every day that took an hour of my time to do, a report to be filed every week that took about three hours over the course of the week, meeting with management to make sure that the first two reports were complete, accurate, and not fudged which took an additional two hours a week, and an end of the month assessment for both spending and time clocked in that took about twelve hours over the course of a month.

So guess where I'm more productive.

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by astrodust on Wednesday March 14, 2012 @06:44PM (#3705815)
I would speculate that you're probably more selective about the kinds of companies you work for than a VC is in funding them.

There have been some legendary turkeys over the last ten years, but for every pets.com or hairdryersbyemail.com there's dozens of others so misguided you never heard a thing, they just went nowhere fast.

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by jessriedel on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @01:14PM (#3699335)
> Of course, when it's private venture capital that's behind this, people don't seem to complain as much.

That's because private venture capital is people spending their own money, rather than other people's money.

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by anigbrowl on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @02:43PM (#3699752)
No it isn't. It's usually a fund manager spending other people's money; if s/he strikes out too many times, the money leaves and the fund closes down.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by astrodust on Wednesday March 14, 2012 @06:45PM (#3705818)
"Taxpayers money" versus "Taxpayers retirement money" is a subtle distinction here, isn't it?
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by Symmetry on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @09:28AM (#3698274)
Japan's record isn't that good - MITI tried to strangle both Japanese auto exports and the semiconductor industry in their cradle because they didn't conform to Japan's development plan.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by astrodust on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @10:51AM (#3698669)
Sony's initial plan was rice cookers.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by adaml_623 on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @08:17AM (#3698042)
Serious question. Was it a disaster or did they just pick the losing team?

Sometimes the government picking a loser can still cause a market to expand.

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by gaius on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @08:26AM (#3698064)
Well, they picked one winner - Leyland - and force-merged them with all the losers, in the hope that Leyland's magic would somehow infuse them. Instead, it destroyed them all. Some of the brands, like Jaguar, Daimler, Land Rover, etc live on. But not as British companies.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by maratd on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @08:38AM (#3698102)
> Was it a disaster or did they just pick the losing team.

The government always picks the losing team. The winning team doesn't want anything to do with the government.

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by cma on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @03:28PM (#3699953)
^dogma
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by maratd on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @05:11PM (#3700454)
My karma ran over your dogma.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by slowpoke on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @10:07AM (#3698462)
The winning team is the one that pays the government, not the other way round.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by GFischer on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @08:30AM (#3698078)
What went wrong with Leyland? It's a very respected trademark here in Uruguay, we still have some Leyland buses in operation here, including 1949 Leyland Olympics (!!!)

It's even on Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leyland-MCW_Olympic

"The Olympic was popular in Montevideo, with 240 entering service in the 1950s and 1960s. 50 of these were new to the Montevideo local authority, most of which passed to major independent and the other customer CUTCSA on privatisation. Some of the 240 were still in use as late as 2001 including a 1951 EL40 in use as a driver trainer."

Edit: kind-of-answered simultaneously here http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3698064 while I was writing the question :)

"they picked one winner - Leyland - and force-merged them with all the losers"

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by arethuza on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @09:52AM (#3698395)
BL was responsible for some of the most ghastly cars ever created, including:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morris_Marina

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austin_Allegro

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by teamonkey on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @11:48AM (#3698925)
I'm not quite sure why the government's choices back then would have any bearing on their choices 30 years later? It's not the same people. It's not even the same generation.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by ataggart on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @06:46AM (#3697813)
The poor state of car manufacturing and banking would seem to argue against inflicting "government investing" on new technology companies.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by chalst on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @08:35AM (#3698091)
The banking industry managed to wreak itself without serious government investment. The trouble was an absence of effective deterrents to bankers seeking dangerously high levels of leverage.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by andrewmu on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @07:51AM (#3697979)
I think many people are assuming this means direct investment but maintaining a high quality, accessible education system is arguably more important.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by jahewson on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @06:17AM (#3697744)
Especially as ARM originated from Acorn, whose success came from manufacturing the BBC Micro, for a publicly funded organisation (the BBC).
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by gaius on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @07:54AM (#3697983)
Ahem, Acorn paid the BBC a fee for every Beeb sold, as a licensing fee on use of the logo.

Acorn were also almost overlooked in favour of a company called Grundy, which had government backing, but inferior technology.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grundy_NewBrain

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by allertonm on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @01:31PM (#3699419)
I actually had a NewBrain, think it's still around in my parents' attic somewhere.

I did quite a bit of real paying work on BBC Micros back in the day, and think they were great - but reading the way people tell the story today, one would be given the impression that the NewBrain was some kind of grim socialist piece of junk. It was actually a pretty decent bit of kit, quite a bit better quality than many of the other micros on the UK market at the time.

In an ironic turn, the company I worked for doing the BBC stuff later moved into Grundy's old premises in Teddington after they went bust.

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by peterstjohn on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @11:03AM (#3698722)
On the other hand, the BBC Micro would almost certainly not have been the success it was without the Beeb and the lift it gave to Acorn in the educational market.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by jahewson on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @12:14PM (#3699055)
Look at it as very well-priced advertising, after all the BBC effectively promoted their product. They nearly lost out to Sinclair Research as well, but that's a well known story...
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by gaius on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @12:54PM (#3699227)
The BBC were careful never to say "Acorn" on-screen (same as they never said Sellotape, it was always "sticky-backed plastic", to the amusement of the entire population).
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @07:35AM (#3697933)
ARM employs about 2 000 people [1]. They're definitely a huge boon for the British tech community and competitiveness, but justifying government support for such a small employee base would be untenable.

[1] http://www.arm.com/about/company-profile/index.php?setcookie...

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by ajross on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @12:18PM (#3699079)
Yes. There's a temptation, because they both "make CPUs" to view ARM as the "next Intel", but it's not like that at all. Intel is an industrial manufacturing company. They happen to manufacture CPUs that they've designed, but "what they do" (or at least, where their money comes from and where the bulk of it goes to) is manufacturing. In the ARM world, all that cash flow goes through TSMC, Samsung, TI, Global Foundries, Fujitsu, etc... Basically none of it goes through the UK.

ARM's model, of course, is absolutely the future of semiconductor design. But it's not going to bring an Intel-sized industry to the UK.

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by sycren on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @08:05AM (#3698009)
Most of the 2000 may be highly skilled or at least a large proportion to that of a bank, increasing funding in such a company may increase the number of people taking up science and engineering disciplines in education.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by Symmetry on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @09:30AM (#3698282)
There's also all the other small companies that benefit from being near ARM, for instance the chip design team in Britain my company picked up.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by gaius on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @07:52AM (#3697980)
Northern Rock employed 5000.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by nl on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @10:17PM (#3701500)
Bank bail-outs aren't about employment, they are about protecting people and other business from losses in assets in the banks.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by arethuza on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @08:28AM (#3698074)
How many of those 2000 are in the UK?
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by lgeek on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @09:21AM (#3698250)
Most of them.
Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by swombat on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @06:45AM (#3697809)
To be fair, via TSB, the UK is investing in new technology companies... not sure how that compares to their investment in car manufacturing, though. However, afaik the main "investment" in banking was to save the banks that were going bust.

Disclaimer: I might be completely wrong about the above!

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by frobozz on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @07:19AM (#3697889)
And yet, according to: http://www.raspberrypi.org/archives/509

"If a British company imports components, it has to pay tax on those (and most components are not made in the UK). If, however, a completed device is made abroad and imported into the UK – with all of those components soldered onto it – it does not attract any import duty at all. This means that it’s really, really tax inefficient for an electronics company to do its manufacturing in Britain"

Re:Arm unveils 1mm x 1mm 32bit chip: "years of battery life" by nl on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @09:19PM (#3701304)
Meh..

ARM only employs ~2000 people, not all of whom are in the UK. That's hardly a mass employer like the manufacturing sector is.