Nova/PBS recently did a number of episodes on the number of tricks your brain is playing on your at anytime. Once you start seeing the shortcuts the brain takes in action the entire process is far less magical.
Because it's still equally nebulous.
No, its not.
Its the quality of “experiencing”.
Which is impossible to define in objective terms; it is the essence of subjectivity on which all other subjectivity rests. It’s not merely “we don’t know how to determine whether an AI or camera has it”, it is categorically impossible to determine if something has it. The popular narrative about which things in the natural world have it has evolved radically over time, but in no case has there been, or could there be, any empirical basis for this; its all just vibes.
And your definition is now circular and can not be used that way.
Hence the claim that the original definitions were nebulous.