It definitely makes for a more wrenching story, but it's hard for me to see how failing outright is somehow better than selling the team and keeping the service alive for 6-9 more months.
Re:Posterous acquired by Twitter
by alextgordon on Monday March 12, 2012 @09:40PM
(#3696598)
Perhaps it's because acquired companies tend to be more useful and more popular than companies that fail. So the cumulative disruption is greater for the acquihires than for the failures.
Or in other words, I would sacrifice many many startups to get EtherPad back again.
Re:Posterous acquired by Twitter
by fatihdonmez on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @04:33AM
(#3697518)
true one
Hard to believe that a team that knows it will be able to be acquihired won't be phoning it in and slacking off. Same as people do when they have taken finals and know that grades don't matter anymore. If you know failure is at the end and not some big prize and do over you will naturally try harder.
I think this is the main differentiating point between 'failing' and 'acquihires' (from a user's perspective).
If a company is simply shutting down, there's some sympathy for the team and it's known that the service will stop. With a talent acquisition, nobody really knows what's going to happen to the service (maybe even the founders don't know) and that extra level of uncertainty is off-putting. [1]
Eventually, that extra level of uncertainty transfers over to the List Of Reasons Not to Work With Startups(TM).
[1] This is also true of straight acquisitions but there's a reasonable expectation that the acquirer is purchasing the product as well as the team.