News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why This AI Moment May Be the Real Deal by tshaddox on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @02:51PM (#36960641)
> "Consciousness" means "an existing stream of experiences".

Those seem equally nebulous.

> "Free will" means "a feeling that one could've made a different choice"

That doesn't seem like the ordinary definition of the term, either in philosophy or in everyday usage. I would think most people would define "having free will" as not just feeling that one could have made a different choice, but rather it actually being physically possible for a different choice to have been made.

> "qualia" means "specific characteristics of experiences that one can attend to"

I think those are also equally nebulous.

> One need not "insist" on anything to believe they are unique characteristics of our identity.

The insistence is necessary, and invariably comes up. As soon as I say to someone "given your definitions of these concepts, I don't think they exist" they will say "well, I've started with the foregone conclusion that I cannot deny the existence of these things, so either you're plainly wrong, or we need to tweak our definitions and understanding of these things."

Re:Why This AI Moment May Be the Real Deal by TaupeRanger on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:19PM (#36961133)
> Those seem equally nebulous.

They aren't. It's literally happening right now as you read this - a stream of experiences is present. If that is the case, YES it is consciousness, if nothing is happening, NO it is not consciousness. Black and white - literally as non-nebulous as you can get.