News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paypal Does it Again by saurik on Monday March 12, 2012 @06:31PM (#3695998)
The notion that pre-orders are scary or generally disallowed has nothing to do with "scams": legitimate people just trying to get business done, who have established names or even good track records, don't always come through on these orders. It is not appropriate for those companies to be mitigating that risk using the credit from their merchant account; in this specific issue, PayPal can even get in trouble for allowing pre-orders to happen using their card providers.

As for Regretsy's continual lack of ability to get CS from PayPal, as someone who has often spent egregious amounts of time talking to PayPal, I honestly think Regretsy is doing something wrong. I also personally feel like PayPal should just ban them from using the service: they don't seem to understand how online payments work, and their reaction to normal procedures is to raise a public shit storm... it's just lame, and it shouldn't be getting play on HN.

Re:Paypal Does it Again by Klinky on Monday March 12, 2012 @06:46PM (#3696061)
As for Regretsy's continual lack of ability to get CS from PayPal, as someone who has often spent egregious amounts of time talking to PayPal, I honestly think Regretsy is doing something wrong.

Customer service != fraud department. Google, Netflix & Paypal seem to have similar methods of dealing with "suspicious accounts". Those methods usually involve something along the lines of shutting the account down and then rebuffing attempts to communicate with the people who made the decision. Customer service evaporates once you've been ostracized by their security systems.

Re:Paypal Does it Again by mgkimsal on Monday March 12, 2012 @09:26PM (#3696562)
I once asked a merchant account provider how larger companies (airlines, for instance) operate by selling stuff way in the future (booking at ticket 5 months in advance, for example), when they were giving me grief about selling a magazine subscription for a year in advance.

"Big reserves on deposit" is what I was told.

It's probably not quite as simple as that, but I suspect being able to demonstrate a degree of financial solvency (airlines? really?) and having funds in reserve would go a long way towards paypal working with you more. In fact, I think paypal ends up holding some of your funds for you as a reserve against chargebacks after certain conditions are triggered, no?

Re:Paypal Does it Again by dedward on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @03:16PM (#3699888)
i believethey actually have to put up money in a reserve account as part of the payment provider agreement..... the merchant doesnt get credit.
Re:Paypal Does it Again by mgkimsal on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @04:58PM (#3700405)
That's what I meant when I wrote "Big reserves on deposit". Maybe it wasn't worded very clearly - sorry.
Re:Paypal Does it Again by dedward on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @02:30AM (#3697272)
"It is not appropriate for those companies to be mitigating that risk using the credit from their merchant account."

If I'm not mistaken, if this were an actual, say, visa merchant account, all parties would have much clearer rules laid out. The customer would be protected "they didn't deliver, I'm not paying". The merchant doesn't get "credit" per-se..... they have to deliver goods or the charge-backs start, at which point they are up shit creek, along with possibly their substantial deposit with their merchant provider.

Paypal does not work like a normal merchant account for credit cards - people need to remember that - that's why we have these horror stories. If a credit card processor tried to pull this stuff they'd have their visa contract yanked in a heartbeat and thir merchant banks would drop them like a hot potato.

Re:Paypal Does it Again by tlholaday on Monday March 12, 2012 @07:05PM (#3696139)
Regretsy is reporting the problem with PayPal CS in this instance, not suffering from it. It appears you commented without reading the article.
Re:Paypal Does it Again by huggyface on Monday March 12, 2012 @08:37PM (#3696414)
The notion that pre-orders are scary or generally disallowed has nothing to do with "scams"

I rather liberally misused scam to mean "sloppy or negligent financials" -- like "let's take lots of pre-orders and with those funds maybe we'll be able to make something happen!" When businesses need to front-load financing from their future customers, the likelihood of failure increases dramatically.