Re:Room-Temperature Ambient-Pressure Superconductor LK-99 pr...
by davidivadavid on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:48AM
(#36957623)
While correct you're being downvoted because you're equivocating on the term "theory." People are assuming you're talking about a fully baked, documented theory couched in precise language and equations. What you're actually talking about is tacit assumptions / models that are built in observations.
"Theory comes first" is particularly unfortunate wording because it seems to imply the naive point of view that people first come up with a thorough mathematical model of some phenomenon before testing and validating it with experiments. That's obviously not how science has worked throughout history.
Saying "all observations/measurements imply an underlying theory" would have been maybe more accurate.
"Theory comes first" is particularly unfortunate wording because it seems to imply the naive point of view that people first come up with a thorough mathematical model of some phenomenon before testing and validating it with experiments. That's obviously not how science has worked throughout history.
Saying "all observations/measurements imply an underlying theory" would have been maybe more accurate.