News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by bjornasm on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:35AM (#36953409)
Why are you just dismissing people with an other viewpoint than you as "those with an axe to grind" that "keep on harping forever and everywhere"? Your complete disregard of others experience and viewpoint is extremely in line with the elements that people dont like about SO.

"So that is your opinion, experience and thoughts? WRONG!". Add in some offhand slights, that will teach them!

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by matsemann on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @04:40AM (#36953790)
Aren't you dismissing my viewpoint that it's not as bad as those claim? Is my experience worth less? I honestly don't get your point.

And nice straw man in your last sentence. Quite ironic while complaining about SO being the toxic ones..

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by AlbertCory on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:02PM (#36960865)
Well, well. If we go to SO we see that a "matsemann" has been a member for 11 years, had 20,000+ reputation points, and is a "publicist" and a "steward".

Maybe that's not you, of course.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by matsemann on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:16PM (#36961068)
Relevant, how?

You're probably going to accuse me of some bias. I'm however going to claim I then know more of the state of SO, given my active membership there...

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by AlbertCory on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @04:39PM (#36962484)
Usually writers do "full disclosure" when their objectivity is open to question.
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by matsemann on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @05:03PM (#36962874)
Wow, what damning evidence! Someone commenting about a forum is a member of said forum! What a scoop, Pulitzer incoming!

Even in my very first post in this discussion, I mentioned review queues and what I feel is wrong with SO recently. It's pretty clear to everyone with reading skills that I'm therefore an active member there. And no sane person would think my "objectivity is open to question" based on me commenting a few lines about an article. I'm not a "writer", I'm just commenting on an article. What a weird thing to demand "full disclosure" of.

(And if you knew anything about SO (which I think one should do when discussing it..), you'd know that the badges you mention is just things normal members can do. I have no extra privileges or responsibility, as you seem to imply)

Edit: the comment I'm replying to has been massively edited since I wrote this.

As for my 15 comments: it's me in the root of the discussion. I'm not all over the comments, I'm just responding to comments in the tree of comments I've started. I don't think that should be discouraged.