Re:Argonne National Lab is attempting to replicate LK-99
by godelski on Saturday July 29, 2023 @02:52PM
(#36923279)
Jobs come with a lot of shitty aspects. Don't get me wrong, I generally don't enjoy reviewing either. But I put a lot of work into it because regardless of what I think, this has a significant effect on real people and their entire livelihoods can depend on this task. Especially those in their early career. One or two publications in a top tier journal can land them that internship or job which snowballs.
So I'd ask you do one of two things, either:
- Review a work with the diligence and care that you wish someone would give to you
or
- Don't review
I'd also appreciate it if you openly recognized how stochastic the system is and that if/when you become in a position where you need to evaluate someone, that you remember this and take it into consideration. It has a lot of value to you too, since if the metric is extremely noisy it doesn't provide you value to heavily rely upon that metric. Look for others.
So I'd ask you do one of two things, either:
- Review a work with the diligence and care that you wish someone would give to you
or
- Don't review
I'd also appreciate it if you openly recognized how stochastic the system is and that if/when you become in a position where you need to evaluate someone, that you remember this and take it into consideration. It has a lot of value to you too, since if the metric is extremely noisy it doesn't provide you value to heavily rely upon that metric. Look for others.