News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Employee Accuses WEI-Opponents of Being “Criminals” by richbell on Friday July 28, 2023 @09:29PM (#36915821)
That's a distinction without a difference in my mind. Claiming that criminals are against the proposal is "poisoning the well", even if he's not accusing _all critics_ of being criminals.

> my suspicion that there is significant intimidation from criminals who are afraid this feature will disrupt their illegal and/or unethical businesses, and I don't give in to criminals or bullies

Re:Google Employee Accuses WEI-Opponents of Being “Criminals” by predictabl3 on Friday July 28, 2023 @09:39PM (#36915888)
The notion that this is poisoning the well is also supported by the general pattern: retreating on an idea that others thought was bad, avoiding literally any discussion of the technical/cultural criticism (despite that it apparently still existed legitimately enough to postpone the proposal for now) and 2/3rd or more of the post spent implying that [all|some|who knows] of the opponents were abusive bullies, and that maybe the idea was actually fine. (Setting the stage to absolutely re-introduce with the new framing "inauthentic traffic" in 6 months.)

Note also, avoiding any discussion of the web open or how it entered into the decision to postpone, supposedly.

I am not emotionally invested because I see this as inevitable and don't care, I'll go live in the woods soon anyway, but this is just icky to read.