News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No One Wants to Talk to Your Chatbot by AndrewKemendo on Thursday July 27, 2023 @04:57PM (#36900073)
My mind has been changed on this recently after I showed a very close friend the Pi app [1]. Almost immediately they were using Pi all day everyday as a kind of "rubber ducky" to process decisions and just generally brainstorm with - the same way you would with a therapist, close friend or colleague.

For example, this person literally has an ongoing chat with Pi to "help find enjoyment in daily life" via the voice interface. Not only that but basic help with research etc... instead of googling. That's amazing and staggering. I mean it's literally like the movie Her (without the romantic subtext).

[1] https://apps.apple.com/us/app/pi-your-personal-ai/id64458159...

Re:No One Wants to Talk to Your Chatbot by sharemywin on Thursday July 27, 2023 @05:13PM (#36900242)
This seems like a shill comment.
Re:No One Wants to Talk to Your Chatbot by AndrewKemendo on Thursday July 27, 2023 @05:25PM (#36900363)
Not sure what to tell you other than it's legit
Re:No One Wants to Talk to Your Chatbot by mocko on Thursday July 27, 2023 @07:20PM (#36901380)
Holy crap, thanks for sharing this. It's the first time a conversational AI has impressed me. I can just about find the edges (short memory, relentlessly positive) but in the space of an hour it's given reasonably good advice on social situations, answered questions about how it works and even recommended some great niche bands based on my existing tastes. Just as you said, its knowledge seems to be extremely broad.

There's a contrast between Pi and the kind of chatbot discussed in the article. When we talk to Pi we don't expect it to do anything for us - it just gives advice and makes suggestions that we can take or leave. The resulting stream of tokens matches our expectations enough to satisfy us.

A chatbot on a company's website however, probably we are talking to that because we want something to happen. "Please fix my account", "my last bill was wrong" etc. As the chatbot isn't integrated with the company's processes it can't actually change the state of the outside world and so talking to it will be a frustrating experience. I wonder if this will improve if/when chatbots get better integrated with systems? Will companies even dare to do this for real?

Re:No One Wants to Talk to Your Chatbot by AndrewKemendo on Thursday July 27, 2023 @10:59PM (#36902701)
I gave it to my kids and they were all creeped out

It’s clearly got issues but it’s tuned to be spookily charming

Very much uncanny valley for chat