Re:It's 2023, so of course I'm learning Common Lisp
by ristos on Thursday July 27, 2023 @04:56AM
(#36890790)
These issues get mentioned a lot, you just haven't noticed I guess. Sourceforge is also an issue with some C libraries too, I'm guessing because it was done a long time ago? not sure.
I use ECL because it has really good C interop. It actually lets you inline C and access macros directly, making it a great glue language for C libraries. It's what I'm using it for now. I think you might even be able to avoid the GC entirely and use it to script C programs together in a performant way, by using the C FFI to allocate and manage the memory, including the ECL types, instead of the GC. And that's actually doable because of how good the inspector/debugger for lisp is. You can even inline assembly. I'm working on a bunch of CL stuff around this sort of thing, I plan to do a writeup of it and share it once I've developed it more.
Lisp has it's downsides, but the C FFI/embeddability, along with the excellent low-level debugger/inspector, interactivity, and conditions and restarts, makes it worth the time for me to invest in it. And the stability of the language. My main gripe is the reader, but it's easy-ish enough to avoid the problems with named-readtables, or a simple lisp parser for `read` or whatever. I like Clojure, but it's missing some key stuff from the old lisp world that I'd love to see. Shadow-cljs is awesome.
I use ECL because it has really good C interop. It actually lets you inline C and access macros directly, making it a great glue language for C libraries. It's what I'm using it for now. I think you might even be able to avoid the GC entirely and use it to script C programs together in a performant way, by using the C FFI to allocate and manage the memory, including the ECL types, instead of the GC. And that's actually doable because of how good the inspector/debugger for lisp is. You can even inline assembly. I'm working on a bunch of CL stuff around this sort of thing, I plan to do a writeup of it and share it once I've developed it more.
Lisp has it's downsides, but the C FFI/embeddability, along with the excellent low-level debugger/inspector, interactivity, and conditions and restarts, makes it worth the time for me to invest in it. And the stability of the language. My main gripe is the reader, but it's easy-ish enough to avoid the problems with named-readtables, or a simple lisp parser for `read` or whatever. I like Clojure, but it's missing some key stuff from the old lisp world that I'd love to see. Shadow-cljs is awesome.