News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Never Negotiate Piecemeal. Here’s Why by nostrademons on Saturday March 10, 2012 @05:55PM (#3688951)
You could look at this by viewing negotiating as a way of arriving at a globally optimal solution that maximizes everyone's happiness, rather than as a way to allocate surplus that's inherently zero-sum.

When you negotiate piecemeal, there's little room for prioritization. There's give & take on each individual issue, and one person is the winner and one person is the loser on that particular issue, and you don't have the flexibility to make sure you win on the issues you care about and lose on the ones you don't.

When you treat the agreement as a whole, you can look at it as an effort in prioritization. Each side will care more about certain issues. You want each side to win on the issues they care about, and lose on the ones that they don't. The negotiation, then, is just a way of teasing those priorities out effectively and making sure that everybody's needs can be met at once.

Re:Never Negotiate Piecemeal. Here’s Why by pbhjpbhj on Saturday March 10, 2012 @08:40PM (#3689302)
Surely this:

>a way of arriving at a globally optimal solution //

has very little direct relationship with this:

>the flexibility to make sure you win on the issues you care about and lose on the ones you don't //

This is the statesmanly way to do things. But generally speaking what one cares about and what is "globally optimal", lets say most beneficial for both parties, is seldom coterminous.

Re:Never Negotiate Piecemeal. Here’s Why by nostrademons on Saturday March 10, 2012 @08:45PM (#3689313)
That's where you trust that both parties will fight hard for what they most want. If you fight as hard as you can for your terms, and they fight as hard as they can for their terms, then presumably all the issues will be laid out on the table and the agreement simply won't get signed unless it's as good as it can be.

It's the same reason that adversarial systems law, economics, international relations, etc. tend to work. People have more information about their own desires than that of others, so if you task each person with looking out for his own interests but ensure that they also respect the clearly-expressed interests of others, you end up bringing as much information to bear as you can.

Re:Never Negotiate Piecemeal. Here’s Why by wisty on Saturday March 10, 2012 @09:28PM (#3689371)
It's also why systems like law, economics, and international relations fail. People don't care about issues which only marginally effect them, so they don't bother.

Take pork barrelling (edit - I used a different example, but it would derail the thread). Nobody (at least, nobody who's notable for anything except being anti-pork) fights to limit it, because no-one loses a huge amount. But a small minority of wealthy vested interests do stand to gain a lot.

But your point is basically correct - the systems mostly work, because people's big issues get dealt with.

Re:Never Negotiate Piecemeal. Here’s Why by philwelch on Saturday March 10, 2012 @08:43PM (#3689309)
If you win on the issues that you care about, the other side wins on the issues they care about, and the two sets don't intersect much, surely you've reached a global optimum?
Re:Never Negotiate Piecemeal. Here’s Why by pbhjpbhj on Sunday March 11, 2012 @06:57PM (#3691528)
I think it swings on the definition of optimal being used I'm assuming optimal with respect to an impartial but omniscient third party.