If you want the job, you'll put in the time. In the process you'll also learn about he skills and culture the company expects, and they'll also be trying to present themselves as an interesting place to work.
It's the same dance, but now you need to be involved from the start.
It makes sense for the company to invest more in finding the employee than the employee invests to find the company; the company has more to gain.
Say it takes 3 hrs to do the application (probably not, but I haven't done one). The resulting candidate pool will be smaller, and consist of more dedicated applicants, who aren't just firing off blanks. I think both the employer and the applicant might get a higher "hit ratio".
If a recruiter has to sift through thousands of resumes, then good talent gets missed, bad talent gets interviews, and 2.5 months later you'll still be unemployed.
Maybe companies could still accept resumes and "regular applications" in addition to the HireArt channel. I think applicants going the HireArt route would be more likely to get consideration/interviews.
This is far more fair for workers in a non-recession than in a recession though -- where desperation will drive large numbers of workers to put in the extra time to get the job.
One big problem you might face- this would make it even harder for HR to do a passable job, requiring even more time from managers within the company.
I think hire art gets in the way of finding talent, but a lot of people looking to make a good connection dont have hours to complete a long list of questions created at the whim of a founder or HR rep.