Re:Why CS people should go to college - lessons from basketball
by philwelch on Friday March 09, 2012 @03:55PM
(#3685887)
So there's two things here, the notion that developers need to go to college, and the analogy to basketball via the notion that NBA players are better off after having played in college. I'm going to expand and examine that analogy first and then draw it back a bit.
The reason for college basketball (as a talent pipeline to the NBA at least) is because college basketball incurs no cost on the NBA or its teams to operate, just like college football for the NFL, but unlike minor league baseball or soccer academies in Europe and (secondarily) run by some MLS teams. The average professional athlete (by which I mean someone who makes their sport the focus of their lives, rather than someone who gets paid), in most team sports, is only ready for top level play in their early 20's anyway, which roughly corresponds to college graduation. So it works out.
I don't know much about minor league baseball, but I do know a bit about soccer. In soccer, different players develop at different rates. Some players, like Lionel Messi or Wayne Rooney, can start as young as 16. More often, a player will break into top-level play between 18 and 21. While some of the more special and talented players will start younger, most players, some world-class, broke through after age 20; goalkeeper Joe Hart broke into top-level play at 22 in 2009, and defensive midfielder Sergio Busquets broke through at age 20 the year before. As far as anyone could tell, this is because those are the ages that those players were ready. But this is because youth players come through academies run by the clubs themselves. If a player is ready at 16, they'll play him. If a player is ready at 22, they'll play him. Just like sometimes a basketball player is ready at 18 and doesn't need college ball.
Of course, it's worth the expense to develop players in specialized academies when players can be worth millions; developers aren't so valuable. But they are just as individuated, and some will be ready at a different age than others, and college isn't necessarily the best way to prepare them.
The reason for college basketball (as a talent pipeline to the NBA at least) is because college basketball incurs no cost on the NBA or its teams to operate, just like college football for the NFL, but unlike minor league baseball or soccer academies in Europe and (secondarily) run by some MLS teams. The average professional athlete (by which I mean someone who makes their sport the focus of their lives, rather than someone who gets paid), in most team sports, is only ready for top level play in their early 20's anyway, which roughly corresponds to college graduation. So it works out.
I don't know much about minor league baseball, but I do know a bit about soccer. In soccer, different players develop at different rates. Some players, like Lionel Messi or Wayne Rooney, can start as young as 16. More often, a player will break into top-level play between 18 and 21. While some of the more special and talented players will start younger, most players, some world-class, broke through after age 20; goalkeeper Joe Hart broke into top-level play at 22 in 2009, and defensive midfielder Sergio Busquets broke through at age 20 the year before. As far as anyone could tell, this is because those are the ages that those players were ready. But this is because youth players come through academies run by the clubs themselves. If a player is ready at 16, they'll play him. If a player is ready at 22, they'll play him. Just like sometimes a basketball player is ready at 18 and doesn't need college ball.
Of course, it's worth the expense to develop players in specialized academies when players can be worth millions; developers aren't so valuable. But they are just as individuated, and some will be ready at a different age than others, and college isn't necessarily the best way to prepare them.