News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Pirate - An Open Letter To Content Creators by Retric on Friday March 09, 2012 @10:50AM (#3684498)
MMO's are digital goods without this problem as is Facebook. Also, many restaurants barely break even on their food and make most of their money selling dramatically overpriced drinks. If you order a ten 99c cheeseburger's from McDonald's they make less money than if you order one 1.50$ soda, yet when you focus on the average customer you sell enough soda for McDonald's to become a multi billion dollar company.

http://adage.com/article/news/double-cheeseburgers-working-t...

Re:Why I Pirate - An Open Letter To Content Creators by rbarooah on Friday March 09, 2012 @10:59AM (#3684540)
No they aren't - they both keep important parts of their software protected and sell an adjunct service.

The MMO server software is heavily protected, and you pay for access to the data center where they run it. MMOs are therefore both protected and funded by the selling of an adjunt service.

Facebook's client software is free but the server software is also heavily protected, and the operation is paid for by selling advertising, also an adjunct service.

Re:Why I Pirate - An Open Letter To Content Creators by Retric on Friday March 09, 2012 @11:19AM (#3684629)
The server side software on most MMO's is a tiny fraction of the overall code. People have reversed engendered World of Warcraft and some people play on private servers. However, in both WOW's and Facebook's case it's the hosting of all that data that's valuable not just the code.

Which comes back to my main point, there are DRM free ways to make piracy irrelevant. If someone was trying to sell a nuclear submarine by walking door to door in a trailer-park people would have no problem suggesting they were an idiot. Yet, for some reason people get all up in arms when someone suggests selling prepackaged media is a poor decision.

Re:Why I Pirate - An Open Letter To Content Creators by rbarooah on Friday March 09, 2012 @11:31AM (#3684692)
How is your point any different to the point I made in the comment you first replied to? Am I missing something?
Re:Why I Pirate - An Open Letter To Content Creators by Retric on Friday March 09, 2012 @03:28PM (#3685782)
When you said:

This implies that the cost of producing unprotected digital goods in general can only be covered by selling some non-digital good or service in conjunction with it.

My impression was you did not agree with this point and where simply bringing it up as a topic of conversation.

Clearly many individuals and companies do make a lot of money selling content. I simply feel that what's needed to keep that model working in the long term is more costly than the value of content it protects.

Re:Why I Pirate - An Open Letter To Content Creators by rbarooah on Friday March 09, 2012 @04:06PM (#3685939)
I don't like it, but I don't disagree with it.

I was bringing it up as a topic of conversation, mostly in the hope that someone would argue against it convincingly, because if such an argument can be made, I'd like to hear it.