Re:Young people are flocking to astrology
by copperx on Monday July 24, 2023 @04:00AM
(#36844414)
Maybe we're getting into the unproductive game of definitions, but perhaps stereotyping is still stereotyping when the categories are completely made up.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Young people are flocking to astrology
by Swenrekcah on Monday July 24, 2023 @05:09AM
(#36844923)
Getting deeper into semantics, I have always understood stereotypes to be an essentially correct general average. Then of course people are so different that the average for a group fits no person in the group more than perhaps 30% so it always ends up being wrong when applied without thought.
But the general stereotype is not “completely made up” so to speak, it’s an observed average.
Then of course some total crap is always thrown in the mix but still.
From the viewpoint of the victims of a stereotype, I doubt that the degree of factual foundation which the stereotype possesses makes much of a difference.
Or based on a misunderstanding, but still coming from a real observation. For example in the US, apparently there used to be a stereotype that polish people are stupid, which came from language differences - polish immigrants had a lot more trouble with English than everyone else, or even were less likely to know any English.
> After all, stereotyping implies incorrect categories.
Well, not neccessarily:
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/insight-therapy/2018...