Re:Linus Torvalds: Programs exist for their users
by anonymoushn on Friday March 09, 2012 @12:52PM
(#3685136)
I would rather ship an extra copy of all of the libraries than tell the user that he has to update libc6 (and therefor almost all of the other software he uses) to run my software.
Re:Linus Torvalds: Programs exist for their users
by icebraining on Friday March 09, 2012 @01:06PM
(#3685201)
Nothing in Linux prevents you from doing so. Just ship your application with it and use a one line shell script to run it with the appropriate LD_LIBRARY_PATH.
It's just not commonly done (with exceptions like http://sta.li/), and as a user, I'm thankful for that.
What happens in Windows is not what you're describing; developers are simply forced to distribute their own copies of the libraries (as DLLs or statically compiled) since there is no package manager. What then happens is that there are dozens of copies of the same libraries, most of them lacking bugfixes and even security patches.
The dependency system used by Linux distros may have its problems, but it surely beats ad-hoc dependency management, even if it requires backporting.
Normal users and especially businesses simply dont want to constantly update their systems. Force them to do that, and they simply walk away.
Right. If you use Windows, have you tried counting the number of update managers running in the background, the number of applications that ask you on launch to "verify updates", the number of times Windows Update alerts you, etc?
Windows machines are constantly updating. Unlike Ubuntu, they just do it incrementally instead of once every six months (except for security patches). But that's better fixed by moving to a rolling release scheme.