Let me repeat your argument back to you. You are saying that classical scholars, purely out of deference for Plato, cannot be trusted to investigate properly just how depraved Spartan society was; and hence Russell is a better authority?
Classics is not the same as history and no serious historians dispute what Sparta was, it’s philosophy or Ancient Greek ones. I suppose since you have Holocaust denier “historians” like you have British Empire revisionists, there must be some Sparta fans lurking under a rock somewhere.
- "noble lies" and propaganda as the basis of the state
- strict separation of the population into castes
- taking children away from their parents and brainwashing them
- killing of political dissidents
Even in Orwell's 1984 parents kept their children, even if they were indoctrinated into squealing on their parents. If anything, it looks more like John Boorman's Zardoz.