> Sparta was a totalitarian state well beyond the wildest dreams of Hitler or Stalin
It was also a polis with rudimentary constitutional checks on its dyadic monarchy and a public ekklesia that notionally approved legislation.
> a disgruntled Athenian aristocrat who resented his social class' loss of power when Athens became a democracy
This is true. He also had prescient complaints about direct democracy as Athens practiced it. Of course, at that time we didn't know direct democracy doesn't work--it careens towards partisan overdrive and ricocheting majoritarianism.
It was also a polis with rudimentary constitutional checks on its dyadic monarchy and a public ekklesia that notionally approved legislation.
> a disgruntled Athenian aristocrat who resented his social class' loss of power when Athens became a democracy
This is true. He also had prescient complaints about direct democracy as Athens practiced it. Of course, at that time we didn't know direct democracy doesn't work--it careens towards partisan overdrive and ricocheting majoritarianism.