News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Moon Landing Was Opposed by Majority of US by nitwit005 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:40PM (#36806441)
NASA was presumably an expensive way to get any inventions not related to space. You could just fund normal research, after all.

People similarly laud military research, but it's not as if you need the military to carry it out. Governments were just willing to fund the research as part of a military effort.

Re:The Moon Landing Was Opposed by Majority of US by renewiltord on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:52PM (#36806593)
Yeah, but if you just fund research without an objective you just waste money because it creates an opportunity for a grifter like me to go there and just not get any results of value.

When you place an objective like the Moon in front, at the least your research has to result in it getting closer. The hope is that this broad objective results in something as opposed to something narrower you might want.

Re:The Moon Landing Was Opposed by Majority of US by ke88y on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:57PM (#36807284)
There's a lot of wisdom here. Stupid but hard goals are still hard goals. Necessity -- not taxpayer largess -- is the mother of all invention.

The corresponding risk is in the resulting cargo cult around arbitrary constraints whose reasons were forgotten. I bet if we committed to building the Panama canal with only spoons we'd have ended up with a lot of amazingly useful spoon-platform earth moving technology, and the commercial sector would've ended up with highly optimized spoon-based machines, and it'd all be very stupid compared to what we got instead.

Re:The Moon Landing Was Opposed by Majority of US by scarface_74 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @06:34PM (#36807666)
Let’s look at Apple before Steve Jobs and Parc research. There was a lot of useless research being done without focus on a shipping product.
Re:The Moon Landing Was Opposed by Majority of US by nitwit005 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @07:57PM (#36808414)
While NASA and the military only fund effective research with practical applications?
Re:The Moon Landing Was Opposed by Majority of US by iancmceachern on Thursday July 20, 2023 @07:46PM (#36808327)
That wasn't one of the choices.

I really love the book "The decision to go to the moon" because it chronicles not apollo itself, but the years leading up to the decision to do it.

Remember: The soviets had just successfully launched sputnik and were years ahead of the US. It was perceived to be a matter of national security and pride, we had to do something.

The choices were:

1 - do it, but as a secret CIA/Pentagon thing focused on military power, objectives, run by the military leadership.

2 - Do it as it was done, as a civilian, public thing for us all to share in.

I, for one, am very grateful they chose 2.

Re:The Moon Landing Was Opposed by Majority of US by edmundsauto on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:41PM (#36808696)
Can you double check the title and maybe add the author? I’d like to pick a copy of this up for my dad.
Re:The Moon Landing Was Opposed by Majority of US by iancmceachern on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:17PM (#36808943)
Its: John M. Logsdon The Decision to Go to the Moon: Project Apollo and the National Interest

I think its out of print. I had to buy it used on Amazon for like 80 bucks when I bought my copy.

Re:The Moon Landing Was Opposed by Majority of US by edmundsauto on Friday July 21, 2023 @05:19PM (#36819933)
Ah there it is, thank you! Is it worth the $50 i see on Amazon?
Re:The Moon Landing Was Opposed by Majority of US by iancmceachern on Sunday July 23, 2023 @02:38PM (#36838279)
Yes! It's very different than the other books I have on Apollo, which are mostly about the engineering and astronauts. This book really answered a lot of questions I had about all the rest of it. The greater economic political and social things going on at the time, the background before. At first it seemed dryer than the other books but it's actually become some of my favorite facts and most discussed details about apollo. If you're into apollo, yes. If you're just into the engineering details and not as much in the politics and societal part maybe not.
Re:The Moon Landing Was Opposed by Majority of US by nitwit005 on Friday July 21, 2023 @04:42AM (#36811501)
I didn't write anything against creating a space program, or state an opinion on who should have run it.