Re:Most caffeine in sodas comes from 1 toxic industrial town...
by Terr_ on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:26PM
(#36765526)
I notice the article doesn't say whether the production of synthetic caffeine is inherently dangerous or polluting, merely that a major source occurs within a polluted/low-regulation place.
I don't see that coincidence--with one item it's not even a correlation--as very compelling. There are great many completely innocuous products or manufacturing steps which could also be located in a place like that for economic reasons.
So it seems another framing could fit: "Synthetic caffeine is so easy to manufacture and so compact to ship that there was a race to the bottom one price, and now it is concentrated somewhere with a very cheap labor costs."
I don't see that coincidence--with one item it's not even a correlation--as very compelling. There are great many completely innocuous products or manufacturing steps which could also be located in a place like that for economic reasons.
So it seems another framing could fit: "Synthetic caffeine is so easy to manufacture and so compact to ship that there was a race to the bottom one price, and now it is concentrated somewhere with a very cheap labor costs."