Re:Ask HN: Why are technical interviews legal while IQ tests...
by pentaphobe on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:00PM
(#36765261)
Good technical interviews are generally looking to see _how_ you approach solving a problem more than whether you can ace it. There are also soft skills being tested like whether you can collaborate, communicate your approach, test assumptions rather than getting caught in a rabbit-hole, etc..
There may be some correlation with IQ as you propose (correlation isn't causation), but I can state unequivocally that there are people who have nailed tech interviews that had lower IQs than people who ... did less well.
Ultimately the premise seems shaky here - technical interviews are testing work-specific competence, not some outmoded and arbitrary "intelligence" metric which (to paraphrase the inventor) _was only ever supposed to be used to test for people who needed extra support_
Or to put it another way: if I'm hiring a carpentry apprentice, I probably want to know if they're likely to hit me or themselves with a hammer.
That likelihood might generally correlate with IQ, but pretty sure there'd be both great and terrible candidates across the full spectrum
There may be some correlation with IQ as you propose (correlation isn't causation), but I can state unequivocally that there are people who have nailed tech interviews that had lower IQs than people who ... did less well.
Ultimately the premise seems shaky here - technical interviews are testing work-specific competence, not some outmoded and arbitrary "intelligence" metric which (to paraphrase the inventor) _was only ever supposed to be used to test for people who needed extra support_
Or to put it another way: if I'm hiring a carpentry apprentice, I probably want to know if they're likely to hit me or themselves with a hammer.
That likelihood might generally correlate with IQ, but pretty sure there'd be both great and terrible candidates across the full spectrum