Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1...
by thetrendycyborg on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @11:11AM
(#3675916)
SimCity Societies doesn't count. That's like saying "The Sims: Urbz" was a part of the Sims series. Different developers just using the brand, it played more like a really dumbed down version of Civ crossed with Spore.
Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1...
by SimHacker on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @01:06PM
(#3676391)
Oh, owch. You had to go mention "The Sims: Urbz", didn't you? I was hoping that was long forgotten. But yes that's a very good analogy between SimCity Societies and Urbz. An unfortunate case of brand dilution: Societies was developed by an outside company, and it didn't have much to do with the original game.
Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1...
by simplefish on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @09:52PM
(#3678409)
To be fair, SimCity Societies was an excellent game. But it was very much a spiritual decendent of Ceasar III and Pharaoh. I think the branding did it more harm than good; the people who love Maxis-style city games disliked Societies, and the people who love Impressions-style city games never bothered to pick it up assuming they would dislike it.
It's an important point, whether the series is returning to it's roots of complexity from ten years ago, or if it will be a continuation of the franchise's modern-day releases. But the article leaves a very confusing impression.
I suppose they might mean to highlight this is the first SimCity game developed by Maxis themselves since 2003, but with Will Wright gone and 10 years of staff turnover, is there really much difference between a SimCity game being developed by "Maxis" instead of by any other outside developer?