News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Citizen scientists observe gamma ray glow associated with... by analog31 on Sunday July 16, 2023 @08:51PM (#36752916)
I read it differently, like the term "amateur scientist" that has been used in the past. To me, it's a term of respect, acknowledging the fact that it's hard to do good science without institutional support, uplifting when someone does it, and spectacular when it's a major discovery.

And oddly enough, people defend science by pointing out that it's like what most people do all the time, but perhaps conducted at a more sophisticated level.

Disclosure: I have "scientist" in my job title.

Re:Citizen scientists observe gamma ray glow associated with... by jasonhansel on Sunday July 16, 2023 @10:09PM (#36753304)
I'm also defending science by, as you say, pointing out that it's like what most people do all the time. But it's precisely for this reason that I don't think that one can draw any clear distinction between scientists and non-scientists or see scientists as somehow distinct from "citizens."

Of course, we can use various terms to describe people belonging to specific institutions or working in specific disciplines, but I don't think it makes any sense to draw a general distinction between "professional scientists," "amateur scientists," and "non-scientists." (Few, I think, consider "amateur" a compliment.)

Re:Citizen scientists observe gamma ray glow associated with... by tsimionescu on Monday July 17, 2023 @03:04AM (#36755004)
"amateur" and "professional" have pretty precise definitions: a professional X is someone who is payed to do X, an amateur X is someone who does X without being payed for it.

So, someone who does science without being paid specifically to do science is quite appropriately named "an amateur scientist".