News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by ponorin on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:14AM (#36746645)
the exclusion zone of fukushima hasn't changed since the beginning even after 10+ years. same for pripyat and chernobyl, those already close to 40 years. UK had to test sheep for radioactivity in certain domestic areas up until 2012.

nuclear damages aren't just dead humans. they come in the forms of lost lands and untrustable food source.

Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by elsonrodriguez on Sunday July 16, 2023 @11:59AM (#36748441)
I’d wager the amount of livable and arable land we’ll lose due to continued fossil fuel usage would be greater than having a Fukushima every year.
Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by Zigurd on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:21PM (#36749396)
This is an interesting argument and let's stipulate it is correct. In that case, take all the oil capex and spend it on power sources that are least costly, least risky, and come on line fastest. Who thinks nuclear is least costly, least risky, and arrives soonest? Anyone? Bueller?
Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by yawaramin on Sunday July 16, 2023 @04:18PM (#36751024)
The problem with those power sources–and this has been pointed out many, many times–is they don't make reliable base load power. The sun doesn't shine at night–no solar power. Winds don't blow on calm days–no wind power.

You are forced to build massive battery farms. Batteries require mining chemicals. For the scale we are talking about, you would be strip-mining the earth.

You are forced to make incredibly costly upgrades to electric grids–some of which are nearly a century old. Because the current grids can't handle the unreliable, wax-and-wane nature of solar and wind power.

You are forced to build gigantic solar panel and wind farms, destroying vast swathes of natural ecology and displacing and destroying many species.

You are forced to deal with solar panels and wind turbines at the end of life problem, especially solar panels which contain toxic chemicals which are at risk of leaching into the environment (think 'water table') unless they are properly disposed of. No one has a viable plan for proper disposal of solar panels at the scale we would have to be talking about.

And finally–the elephant in the room. The giant energy corporations just won't transition to renewable energy if they don't get a high-enough return on their investments. They want something like 12% ROI. This is extremely unlikely. They've left all their commitments to go renewable conditional so they can weasel out by saying it's not cost-effective for them. Just look at what's happening in reality: https://www.cnbc.com/2023/06/23/siemens-energy-scraps-profit...

Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by Zigurd on Sunday July 16, 2023 @05:13PM (#36751462)
Nothing about renewables is speculative. Renewables build-out is the largest share of energy capex. If renewables were "destroying many species" it would be all over the news. The 1980s called and wants their "solar will never..." argument back.
Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by yawaramin on Sunday July 16, 2023 @06:44PM (#36752160)
If that's your only response to all my points, then I think we're done here.
Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by pfdietz on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:15AM (#36758506)
The intermittency of renewables adds costs, but these costs are finite and declining. At this point it's likely that going with renewables will be cheaper than going with nuclear, especially as one projects these declines into the next couple of decades (when any nuclear plant started now will have to compete with improved renewable and storage technologies.)

A quote:

https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9837910

"On the History and Future of 100% Renewable Energy Systems Research"

"With every iteration in the research and with every technological breakthrough in these areas, 100% RE systems become increasingly viable. Even former critics must admit that adding e-fuels through PtX makes 100% RE possible at costs similar to fossil fuels."

Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by yawaramin on Monday July 17, 2023 @02:12PM (#36761868)
Theoretical price decreases are not, in fact, convincing fossil fuel companies to get into renewables when they are making record-breaking profits from FF: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jul/16/big-oil-clim...

The plan by RE people is 'Let's hope that a hundred different unlikely events all line up exactly right, and we'll be able to go fully RE'. This is not a realistic plan. If you did software engineering like this, you would be laughed out of the room (and then fired).

Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by pfdietz on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:16PM (#36781067)
Fossil fuel companies would have no special advantage in most renewable and storage technologies, so it's rational they'd try to stick with what they're good at for as long as possible, perhaps even going down with the ship and returning value to the shareholders as they collapse.
Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by krupan on Sunday July 16, 2023 @12:06PM (#36748504)
How big are the areas that solar farms cover compared to that exclusion zone?

How big will the exclusion zones of Climate Change be if we keep burning fossil fuels?

Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by yellowapple on Sunday July 16, 2023 @06:27PM (#36752058)
Out of curiosity, I decided to do some napkin math on this.

The Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Plant produced 4.7GWe when it was operational, and its current exclusion zone covers an area of 230 square miles - or 0.0204 GW/mi^2.

The US has (according to https://elements.visualcapitalist.com/how-much-land-power-us...) 102.9GWe of solar capacity covering an area of 965 square miles - or 0.1GW/mi^2.

Judging by that, a nuclear disaster's exclusion zone is worse than that of a "solar disaster" (so to speak).

However, the Fukushima plant itself occupies 1.34375 square miles - putting its normal-operation figure at 3.498 GW/mi^2. That's considerably better than the land area occupied by a Fukushima-equivalent solar installation. The question, therefore, is whether a better worst-case figure for land destruction justifies a substantially-worse best-case figure; I don't think it does, but I understand that not everyone would agree.

Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by pfdietz on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:18AM (#36758532)
If you look at the value delivered per acre by a solar field, it's massively (orders of magnitude) higher than the value delivered by a farm.

If land cost rules out solar, it also rules out agriculture. I never see the nuke bros saying we shouldn't grow things because it uses too much land, or that we need to go vegan to reduce land use.

Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by krupan on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:24PM (#36766120)
What are you talking about? It’s not all dollar cost. You can’t eat what a solar farm produces. A solar farm does not replaced the carbon sequestration of a forest. Endangered species displaced by solar farms (desert tortoises, for example), do not benefit from the “value” produced by a solar farm, quite the opposite! This is what the “nuke bros” are talking about!
Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by pfdietz on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @08:54PM (#36780940)
We can assign monetary value to things and then compare them. Food, for example, has value mostly because of enjoyment, not because we absolutely have to eat (the elasticity of demand for beef is an example of this.) The value of the ecosystems displaced by farming, PV, or other land using activities can also be assigned a monetary value (since it's clearly seen as tradeable against economic benefits.)

Given that, we can ask what's the ratio of the value of the output of a farm to the value of the displaced natural ecosystem, and do the same for PV. And if we do that, we will find the ratio is MUCH higher for PV than it is for farming.

So, if the goal is to maximize utility for a given displacement of natural ecosystems, we come out ahead (on the margin) if we use land for PV instead of farming. If we want to return land to nature at lowest cost we would do that by returning farmland to nature, not PV land.

Re:Nuclear Fission Fuel Is Inexhaustible (2022) by yellowapple on Friday July 21, 2023 @01:28AM (#36810310)
> If land cost rules out solar, it also rules out agriculture.

Land cost rules out solar because there are alternatives which do not cost nearly as much in land (barring, per above, preventable and rare disasters). The same can't be said about agriculture; there ain't (to my knowledge) some agricultural equivalent of a nuclear power plant. Vertical farming might be it someday, but so far that hasn't panned out at scale.

> I never see the nuke bros saying we shouldn't grow things because it uses too much land, or that we need to go vegan to reduce land use.

We "nuke bros" ain't saying we shouldn't use PV at all, either. Solar panels:

- Are much more portable than nuclear plants

- Can be deployed in a wider range of locations than nuclear plants (Have you tried putting a molten-salt reactor on a rooftop? Solar's great for that!)

- Are great at providing energy for peak loads, energy to be stored later, and energy for things that don't typically need to be powered when there's no sunlight (e.g. air conditioning)

Solar panels have their place even in a world powered primarily by nuclear.

Likewise, livestock animals:

- Are much more portable than crop fields

- Can be raised in a wider range of locations than most crops (Have you tried growing corn on a mountain? Chickens and goats are great for that!)

- Taste good, produce byproducts that taste good (like eggs and milk), and provide nutrients that are harder to come by in vegan diets without either supplements or additional planning (e.g. multiple different crops).

Animal products have their place even in a world fed primarily by plant products.

Given this: yeah, by all means work toward reducing agriculture's land footprint - but that effort's independent from the effort to reduce the energy sector's land footprint, so it really shouldn't be surprising that people advocating for the power-per-land effort won't automatically start talking about the food-per-land effort in a conversation about power.