News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by mulmen on Saturday July 15, 2023 @05:39PM (#36741200)
Vast swaths of the population are uninteresting rubes. Reddit, Facebook, and Twitter are all doing us a favor by keeping those people occupied and their drivel contained.
Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by RGamma on Saturday July 15, 2023 @06:20PM (#36741461)
The MSM/MEM as population control vehicle/idiot honeypot is a salient angle though you quickly get into self-fulfilling prophecy stuff there. Perhaps it's me being overly pessimistic, but I too might have been captured by the mind-rot matrix if I had grown up with that shit, never knowing what was or could be.
Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by mulmen on Saturday July 15, 2023 @06:30PM (#36741527)
The web isn’t going to help there. Crackpots made websites too.

You aren’t responsible for what other people do. Just live your own life.

Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by RGamma on Saturday July 15, 2023 @07:12PM (#36741777)
I'm not and yet the fate of a population is not arbitrary. MSM is society-level technology and it's clearly doing something to it that would not have happened in its absence.

I'm seeing it in personal acquaintances, who get lost in the information garbage sphere and struggle to contextualize the places that unfavorably shape their belief system (not talking about niche crackpot sites, but trash media here).

This is the polar opposite of what I had hoped would happen with this technology before it got captured by economic incentives. And it's also not what would have happened, had this mold not proliferated, and slower but curated systems prevailed.

It's not all terrible, there's resilience and adaptation. And yet I cannot stop feeling we're dealing with a quite unwelcome phenomenon that weakens a sizable part of us who would profit from a more controlled information environment the most (the dumb get dumber, the smart get smarter, and everyone gets more distracted and fickle).

Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by mulmen on Saturday July 15, 2023 @07:26PM (#36741872)
What do you mean by MSM? To me that is “mainstream media”. I don’t understand how that is applicable here.
Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by RGamma on Saturday July 15, 2023 @08:09PM (#36742122)
Mainstream social (or entertainment) media, by which I mean all the content consumption apps your typical non-tech parents or acquaintances in that age group know about (in my case Instagram, Facebook and ragebait meme groups but luckily not yet TikTok; the wider web outside news sites is pretty much unknown).

Reddit or Mastodon for instance I would not call mainstream from my standpoint, but I left the former site many years ago and have no idea about its current popularity (my only contemporary use is when it pops up in my searches as a sort of wildcard forum).

Sorry, if that's not the usual usage of MSM.

Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by mulmen on Sunday July 16, 2023 @11:53AM (#36748379)
MSM usually means "Main Stream Media". So like broadcast and cable news and conventional newspapers. Overloading it to refer to social media is really confusing because social media is pretty much the opposite thing.

"Entertainment news" is a sub-genre of MSM, typically you see this on the cable news channels or the "opinion" section of a newspaper.

If you get your news from Facebook you aren't getting it from "the MSM" as that term is generally understood. I guess you could coin MSSM for "Main Stream Social Media" to differentiate Twitter from Mastodon (or Reddit from HN?) but honestly I think you can just type out "social media" and not die of fatigue.

Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by Finnucane on Saturday July 15, 2023 @07:26PM (#36741868)
Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by stOneskull on Saturday July 15, 2023 @10:40PM (#36742997)
who _wasn't_ talking about skull and bones in 2003
Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by phatskat on Sunday July 16, 2023 @12:29PM (#36748761)
I’m relistening to the behind the bastards on the Illuminati so…still talking about it to this day lmao
Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by devjab on Sunday July 16, 2023 @02:27AM (#36744194)
Isn’t hacker news doing the same thing for the most parts? This is a little rude but I went through your history and maybe you should be more careful who you call “uninteresting rubes” and “drivel”.

Don't get me wrong, I don't think you're in the category. I don't think anyone is. I'm just poking a little at your self awareness and your lack of respect toward your fellow people. I do think there is an issue with the walled gardens, but I don't think it's the people who use them. It's the psychological effect of having affirmation systems tied to everything you post. I'm sure most people would post waaaaaaaay less "uninteresting" content if it wasn't because of the dopamine chase. I'm guilty of it myself. I try to ask myself if I'm really trying to contribute or if I'm just posting to get likes, and sometimes it prevents me from posting things to social media sites. There are a lot of time where it doesn't though. You may not put much value in Reddits karma system, but what value do you put into your hacker news account? I know from my own experience that it's been fairly healthy for me to create a new account every time I reach a 1000 points. I hope that I'll eventually get to the point where I don't have to do that, but I'm not sure I'm there yet.

It's obviously up to you, but I'd encourage you to not so blatantly disregard other people for what they post on social media. Because social media is a game for our attention, and most of us chase that sweet dopamine rush, even though everything we post on social media sort of disappears after a day and is frankly invisible in the sea of sameness posted by our peers.

Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by antigonemerlin on Sunday July 16, 2023 @02:47AM (#36744286)
Speaking as someone else, I go on reddit because there are occasional domain experts. It's 99% repetitive drivel (I myself am guilty of the same) and 1% person who actually knows what they're talking about.

That number is proportional to %experts/%non-experts, and is inversely correlated with the size of a subreddit (though the AskHistorians subreddit remains an excellent exception), and is the reason why the NonCredibleDefense is usually more credible than the CredibleDefense.

I personally drifted to hackernews from reddit as a general "reddit", but I find it's probably wise to take with a grain of salt the legal/maths/physics/economics/"anything not related to computer science" opinions of the people here. It's probably a good general rule of thumb to only take advice from experts in their domains.

Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by phatskat on Sunday July 16, 2023 @12:26PM (#36748712)
I’m a Reddit expat, the only app that made it usable is dead now so here I am. I know I won’t find talk on Dead Cells tips or Rocket League coaching, but at least there’s lots of good tech discussion and occasional political shitposting that feeds that part of my soul
Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by ThatOldBastard on Sunday July 16, 2023 @06:27AM (#36745358)
A consensual thinker at work, always trying to please the group by public shaming and by underhanded, subversive while ostentaciously well meaning, carmouflaged attacks on free and independent thinkers. Who apointed you to act as the thought police? How about you go to your beloved fellow people and post your utterly subversive, meaningless drivel there instead of trying to infect the minds of commentators here with your manipulative tactics? It is not your job to tell others what to think and how to think about other people, period. Your attempt at censorship has been noted, imho you appear to be a troll or disinformation agent.
Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by ThatOldBastard on Sunday July 16, 2023 @06:31AM (#36745375)
Fully agree with you there!
Re:Every time you click this link, it will send you to a ran... by phatskat on Sunday July 16, 2023 @12:23PM (#36748686)
That’s incredibly reductive and shows you maybe don’t spend time in these spaces based on your perceptions? Many of my friends are talented makers who use social media to communicate about what they do with friends and fans. I’ve learned a lot about knitting and crochet through finding people with those skills on social media. I’ve made strong personal connections with strangers far far from me. I’ve found groups to share and debate and discuss topics important to me.

And acting like “quarantining” people to keep them out of your other online spaces is a good thing? Gross. More access and spread of information helps everyone become more interesting, it spurs innovation, it fosters creativity.

I came to HN after the Reddit API stuff killed Apollo, and though I’ve been here before from search engines, I’m now really getting into the community. It’s been great to see different things and feel inspired to look at how I do thinks in my profession. I wish I had really spent more time here sooner, but fortunately for you I was relegated to my drivel on Reddit until now.