Re:Should Ukraine Negotiate with Russia?
by agrcola on Saturday July 15, 2023 @05:14AM
(#36735005)
Putin argues there is no such thing as Ukraine. The unfortunate truth is there is no such thing as Russia, there's only the current leader, the Tzar, and currently that person is Putin. If somebody wants Ukraine to negotiate with Russia they have to understand that it means negotiating with one single person. We shouldn't do that. That means going back hundreds of years.
I think the article is well informed but generally I feel that there's a huge misunderstanding of what Russia is. We are not talking about a state like Great Britain or USA. It's not even like China. Russia is more like the Mongol Empire, vast area of land consisting many ethnic groups, all controlled with violence and tyranny. Russia has no functioning government (season 3 of Jack Ryan got this completely wrong), there is no legislation and everything is based on corruption. The toughest and most brutal leader wins. If you can demonstrate those qualities, you get to be the Tzar, and enough people will cheer for you (and expect something in return). Prigozhin was close.
Russia is hundreds of years behind Western democracies, so far behind and so alien us living in Western democracies don't even fully recognize it. And the current Tzar (or should I say Khan) is about to be displaced again. In retrospect Putin did everything wrong. Turmoil will follow. There will be opportunities too, just like the last time.
A lot of the Eastern European states were once part of the Russian Empire or the Soviet Union. Some broke free when bolsheviks took control, some broke free when Soviet Union fell. It will not end there, there are still dozens of ethnic groups looking for a way out of Moscow's tyranny. We should make sure those people have our support.
My people were once part of the Russian Empire, we broke free, and now we enjoy prosperity and happiness (happiest people in the world!). Had we not done that our grandparents would've been deported somewhere to Siberia to die and most of us wouldn't even exist.
I think the article is well informed but generally I feel that there's a huge misunderstanding of what Russia is. We are not talking about a state like Great Britain or USA. It's not even like China. Russia is more like the Mongol Empire, vast area of land consisting many ethnic groups, all controlled with violence and tyranny. Russia has no functioning government (season 3 of Jack Ryan got this completely wrong), there is no legislation and everything is based on corruption. The toughest and most brutal leader wins. If you can demonstrate those qualities, you get to be the Tzar, and enough people will cheer for you (and expect something in return). Prigozhin was close.
Russia is hundreds of years behind Western democracies, so far behind and so alien us living in Western democracies don't even fully recognize it. And the current Tzar (or should I say Khan) is about to be displaced again. In retrospect Putin did everything wrong. Turmoil will follow. There will be opportunities too, just like the last time.
A lot of the Eastern European states were once part of the Russian Empire or the Soviet Union. Some broke free when bolsheviks took control, some broke free when Soviet Union fell. It will not end there, there are still dozens of ethnic groups looking for a way out of Moscow's tyranny. We should make sure those people have our support.
My people were once part of the Russian Empire, we broke free, and now we enjoy prosperity and happiness (happiest people in the world!). Had we not done that our grandparents would've been deported somewhere to Siberia to die and most of us wouldn't even exist.