Also, I absolutely loved the fanfic "Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality" written by the forum's creator.
** Edit **
And for the record, my comment wasn't intended to be an accurate depiction of you specifically, which honestly wasn't very effectively conveyed.
It was to highlight a common 'type of person' who make authoritative statements on areas they're not 'experts' in, through no malice on their part, rather as a function of their default mode of behavior.
As others who replied to me highlighted, there are at least two of these people in the world and I wanted others to at least be aware of their existence and point of view; the end goal of this being they might offer others the benefit of the doubt and perhaps some constructive feedback instead of unproductive criticism in similar exchanges.
In essence, I thought other comments were being too hard on you and wanted to point out a potential scenario in which their critiques were at at best unproductive.
You may not realize it but not everyone on the internet is nefarious and if you were to speak in this analytical way about say a classmate while they were in ear shot - that person would likely be quite upset.