News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by wildrhythms on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:38PM (#36703182)
It's not fraud. I get what you're saying with the operational concern trying to locate an unaccompanied minor who was supposed to be at the gate and is now 'missing'. But he paid the price the airline posted for the ticket. Who got defrauded?
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by NoZebra120vClip on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:51PM (#36703281)
The passenger asserts at booking that "I will be at the boarding gate before the plane leaves because I intend to occupy seat X on your aircraft" but that's a lie, because they have no such intention to board the aircraft. That's the fraud, and that's why it's low-grade, because people miss flights accidentally for numerous reasons, this is just a deliberate missing of a flight, and taking away resources from someone else who should have them. Although overbooking, bumping, and standby are all policies in place to deal with the inevitable missed flights, whatever their reason.
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by circuit10 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:08PM (#36703406)
Booking a flight and then not getting on it isn’t fraud. By this logic buying a sandwich and then not eating it should be fraud because you implied that you intended to eat it then didn’t
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by NoZebra120vClip on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:17PM (#36703467)
If I buy the last sandwich, then I've deprived someone else of that sandwich by purchasing it. In case you haven't noticed, seats on an aircraft are a limited resource. You make a "reservation" to declare that you intend to occupy that seat, and the corollary is that nobody else will be able to occupy it. If enough fraudsters reserve seats without using them, the airline has another problem. Say they loaded the galley with 100 peanut packets because 100 passengers promised to board, but now there's only 20 on the flight, what are we gonna do with all these peanuts?

As I mentioned, airlines have plenty of policies to deal with reserved but unused seats, but you've still intentionally taken away a finite resource because you wanted to save a couple bucks.

Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by blibble on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:26PM (#36703529)
> As I mentioned, airlines have plenty of policies to deal with reserved but unused seats

the ticket on the second leg had been paid for

> but you've still intentionally taken away a finite resource because you wanted to save a couple bucks.

it's really going to blow your mind when you realise airlines do the reverse all the time

they call it "overbooking"

knowingly selling the same seat twice? sounds like "low level fraud" by your definition

Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by circuit10 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @06:15AM (#36707014)
> If I buy the last sandwich, then I've deprived someone else of that sandwich by purchasing it.

It’s not considered fraud though

Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:36PM (#36711995)
It's not fraud but how many people are going to laud the virtue of purchasing a sandwich to throw it away?
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by circuit10 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:24PM (#36713818)
It’s not good but I feel like it should be blamed on the airline’s pricing structure
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by gruez on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:51PM (#36704128)
The key difference is that the sandwich didn't come with a terms of carriage, and a ticket does.
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by d0gbread on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:11PM (#36703423)
You should see how much fraud I commit with my gym membership.
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by NoZebra120vClip on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:18PM (#36703472)
So many people have unused gym memberships that the gym can afford to purchase 3 new treadmills every year. Seems like a fair tradeoff.

But you've strawmanned this. Do you go to the gym, put your towel down on the leg press machine, and then go to the juice bar for a drink? Because that's what we're discussing here: taking away a finite resource so that others can't use it.

People with unused gym memberships who don't show up haven't promised anything. They didn't make an appointment with a personal trainer, they don't have machines reserved, there's no implicit contract to exchange limited resources for a membership fee. Your membership fee gives you access to these resources, not a guarantee of their usage. If you go to the gym and every treadmill is in use, then you don't get a treadmill for now. You just wait for a treadmill.

Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by rpearl on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:54PM (#36703750)
evidently the airline priced that resource at a negative value. (Florida to Charlotte $X, Florida to Charlotte to NY $X-$Y.) so apparently that resource was worse than useless.
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by gruez on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:53PM (#36704155)
It's only negative if you think airline's pricing model is something simple like "distance traveled * cost per mile", which isn't the model that airlines with advanced revenue management systems use.
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by rpearl on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:07PM (#36704235)
From a black box perspective it's easy to conclude that it's negative.
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by e93849 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:03PM (#36703381)
It might be wasteful, but wasting resources to save money isn’t fraud.
Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by mthoms on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:07PM (#36703878)
The airline asserts at booking that they will "grant me exclusive access to seat X on a specific flight from A to B" but that's a lie, because they have no intention to honour the contract if they are overbooked (or if they don't sell enough tickets and the flight is cancelled).

When the consumer does something to save money you call it "fraud". When the airline does it, it's okay because "policies"? Putting aside the asinine "contract" for a second, how is one morally correct, while the other isn't?

Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by gruez on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:57PM (#36704179)
> The airline asserts at booking that they will "grant me exclusive access to seat X on a specific flight from A to B" but that's a lie, because they have no intention to honour the contract if they are overbooked (or if they don't sell enough tickets and the flight is cancelled).

This is a moot point because they never promised exclusive access in the first place.

>Putting aside the asinine "contract" for a second, how is one morally correct, while the other isn't?

This just moves the goalposts to an area where anything goes. You could argue that skiplagging is morally correct, because your morals are "corporations are scum, consumers are always in the right", or take a hardcore deontological view that any sort of lying/misrepresentation is morally wrong.

Re:Teenager detained at airport after trying to use “skiplag... by mthoms on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:51PM (#36712261)
>This is a moot point because they never promised exclusive access in the first place.

That's the implied deal when they sell you the ticket. It's the public perception. Only in the fine print does it says otherwise. Hence, that's why people are so outraged when it happens to them.

I'd also argue that the corporation's contract with the consumer is not fair because there is a gross imbalance of power. Airlines (as a group) can put almost anything they want and the consumer has no recourse (except meek consumer protection laws).

Anyways, I just found it interesting that you jumped at the opportunity to vociferously call what the consumer did "fraud" but what the airlines do (ie double booking) as normal business.

While it's correct in a legal sense, I don't think that's a very interesting discussion. The contract is the contract, sure. But the big picture deserves examination also.

>This just moves the goalposts to an area where anything goes.

No, we were discussing a very specific situation. Don't do that.