News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by dnissley on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @12:43PM (#36683555)
I find the whole thing to be a tempest in a teapot -- why is the FTC involved in this at all? For christ's sake it's a video game! If we were discussing access to some critical resource I would understand, but how is this not a criminal waste of our government's time and resources? It reminds me of the congressional baseball steroid hearings.

Am I totally off base here? Can anyone explain to me why this case is so critical?

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by Larrikin on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @12:46PM (#36683615)
You're totally off base. Video games are not just kids stuff. The industry makes nearly three times more money than the film industry. This is exactly the kind of stakes that FTC should be getting involved in.
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by dnissley on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @12:59PM (#36683830)
Both of these industries are entertainment though -- and to me at least it seems there's a pretty limited amount of consumer harm that could come from various IP exclusivity deals.

Again -- am I thinking about this wrong? What is the consumer harm that could result from the moving of IP from one company to another? A truly dedicated fan has to buy a different console to play their favorite game? Non-truly dedicated fans play one of the hundreds of other FPS games on the market that work with their console of choice?

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by xboxnolifes on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @01:32PM (#36684366)
The point is to make sure there is always another console you could move to, and that there is a hundred other fps titles on the market.
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by johnnyanmac on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:12PM (#36696820)
yes, all 2 alternatives. Much choice.

There is always phones and PC for "open platform" at least.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by firebirdn99 on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @02:55PM (#36685629)
The FTC is getting involved, because the goal is to make Big Tech smaller not more bigger, and more dominant through acquiring independent studios with major titles, such as they did with $7B Bethesda, and now 65B+ Activision deal. These are huge IPs, that have large amounts of players, and can give a company like MSFT huge control in gaming, and in the metaverse,etc in the future, which is another nascent field. But far off, that they have not mentioned it in the case or with the public.
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by dnissley on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @04:17PM (#36686663)
How would players be harmed by an IP changing hands and being made exclusive on a particular platform?
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by firebirdn99 on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @08:34PM (#36689014)
For one, lack of consumer choice. To play those games, I would need to buy an Xbox, whereas for the last 20 years, Call of Duty, etc. has been multiplatform.
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by dnissley on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @09:10PM (#36689278)
That's literally one game. That's it. Lack of consumer choice when it comes to a single title shouldn't be something that the FTC is getting involved in. Even when you expand that to all the titles that activision/blizzard produce we're talking a tiny drop in a literal ocean of consumer choice.
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by firebirdn99 on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:34PM (#36689806)
Activision has dozens of famous titles, and a huge IP catalog from the 80's which they can make 100's of exclusives. The $68 Billion price tag tells itself of it's importance in gaming.
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by firebirdn99 on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:46PM (#36689884)
Should corporations the size of Microsoft (almost 25x of Sony, the 2nd nearest competitor) be allowed to make acquisitions of this size to grow itself, and weaken competition. Antitrust law is one of the FTC's mandates, then this is what they are tasked to do.

When (tech) corporations are too big, I can think of many ways it can cause destruction to society. Only have to look at Facebook in the 2016 election. And tech companies will continue to grow, and become too big to fail, unless reigned upon as with past crises, like with banks. Only this time, they have all your information, can surveil you, etc, and with AI pretty soon.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by johnnyanmac on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:18PM (#36696933)
>Should corporations the size of Microsoft (almost 25x of Sony, the 2nd nearest competitor) be allowed to make acquisitions of this size to grow itself, and weaken competition.

Sure. Becuase they aren't even a monopoly in the gaming space to begin with. If you could simply outspend to become a major gaming competitor, Amazon should be #1 by now.

It's clearly not that simple so I'm not concerned about Sony suddenly declining. And meanwhile, Nintendo sits in its own throne above Sony/MS as if it's watching two children on a playground.

> I can think of many ways it can cause destruction to society. Only have to look at Facebook in the 2016 election.

Do you really think a loosely historical shooter game most people use to compete against one another will be used to control information for national elections? I simply don't see it, but who knows?

Even if so: the big issue with that comparison is that your grandparents aren't playing COD. Mine were on FB around that time.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by midoridensha on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:05PM (#36689646)
>To play those games, I would need to buy an Xbox

Then play a different game.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by firebirdn99 on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:38PM (#36689833)
what are the pros for this merger in your opinion if you are neutral?
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by ESMirro on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @08:41PM (#36689055)
You answer your own question in the question…
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by majormajor on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @08:58PM (#36689189)
Why does it matter that it's entertainment?

If at some point consumers have to pay more than they would in a more competitive market, how is that not harm? If you believe that this is a move that will result in less consumer choice and more possibility for MS to extract more $$$$, then you don't like it.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by midoridensha on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:04PM (#36689643)
>If at some point consumers have to pay more than they would in a more competitive market, how is that not harm?

No one HAS to pay for entertainment. It's a pure luxury. There's tons of things you can do with your free time besides playing video games (let alone brand-new AAA console titles): go outside, take a hike, play an instrument, take up a hobby, socialize, learn to cook, write your own software, I could go on and on. You can even do other forms of entertainment with your time: watch a movie or TV series, watch YouTube, watch a sports game, actually play in a sports game, play retro video games on archive.org or in an emulator, etc. All these things compete with (modern Activision) video games for time.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by swift532 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:50PM (#36699841)
Well if you take it to the point of absurdity, then we only have to maintain a competitive market for grain and water.
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by dnissley on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:15PM (#36703451)
I'm not sure this is absurdity. The point is that no company could possibly have an abusable monopoly on entertainment because A) the sheer variety of things there are to do for entertainment, B) the incredibly low barriers to entry in entertainment, and C) that even if there were some entity that gained control over some significant portion of it, that vast majority of people would just do something, anything else rather than submit to such a monopolist's demands. They might be grumpy about it on some level, but that's hardly rising to the level of consumer harm. You might say there is still the case of some tiny number of incredibly dependent people who would continue playing and paying for certain titles no matter the cost, but that is their decision -- they are not without agency to simply say no, and so even that doesn't rise to the level of consumer harm.
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by midoridensha on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:35PM (#36704036)
As I mentioned in another comment, what if, after completing this acquisition, MS decided to raise the price of CoD to $100,000 per player per year? Would this really harm consumers? Would people really be forced to sell their homes and kidneys?

Of course not. They'd just play another game, or watch a movie or something.

If someone wants to play video games, they can do it for free on archive.org, and all they need is a web browser.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by johnnyanmac on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:11PM (#36696796)
>Why does it matter that it's entertainment?

Because it's not a material good that gets in the way of my ability to live. And I say that despite working in entertainment. If a dam breaks down or is owned by some coporate entity that means people may not have access to water.

If Disney owns every single videgame/movie/music/etc and I detest Disney... I find some other pasttime. Hell, maybe I just focus more on foreign media. Sucks for my work but I can find a new job outside of the Mouse. It's a relative minor impact.

>If at some point consumers have to pay more than they would in a more competitive market, how is that not harm?

that's my exact issue. If I can't pay for insulin, I die. if I can't afford COD 2025... what? I don't get to play a video game? Is that "harm" in the traditional sense?

> If you believe that this is a move that will result in less consumer choice and more possibility for MS to extract more $$$$, then you don't like it.

Me not liking something =/= harm. I don't like mushrooms but I wouldn't say they harm me. I just don't like the texture or taste.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by abduhl on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @12:46PM (#36683620)
This case is the latest loss to the FTC as they try to implement Lina Khan’s pro-foreign-corporation and anti-US-tech policies. See https://www.npr.org/2023/03/07/1161312602/lina-khan-ftc-tech

Thankfully the most anti-US consumer policies have pretty much been rejected by actual courts (aka not the farcical administrative “courts” the FTC has) at every turn.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by ahstilde on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @03:56PM (#36686455)
???

How is Lina Khan "pro-foreign-corporation" ?

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by throwawy1934593 on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @03:50PM (#36686388)
I don't think you get how much money is involved in video games now days

The last Call of Duty game crossed a billion dollars in 10 days

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by dnissley on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @04:14PM (#36686633)
Money in itself is not an argument for FTC involvement. E.g. the wedding industry is also enormous, within an order of magnitude of the video game industry in the US.
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by failuser on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @08:49PM (#36689117)
If weddings were monopolized by General Vowes then it would have been a duty of FTC to look into it.
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by dnissley on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @09:06PM (#36689253)
That's just it though -- video games are not "monopolized" in any meaningful sense. A particular IP may be "monopolized" -- e.g. owned by a particular company that has more or less of an interest in producing cross platform versions. But that's not really a monopoly, is it?
Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by failuser on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @09:11PM (#36689286)
Sony and Microsoft are buying game developers left and right. Will the courts allow Microsoft to buy Sony gaming business?

Microsoft is also getting ready to eat Steam’s lunch for a while on the PC side. Will that be allowed to go through?

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by dnissley on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:30PM (#36689780)
> Will the courts allow Microsoft to buy Sony gaming business?

Why not? What would it matter to the players on these consoles? Is demand for certain titles so price insensitive that Microsoft could then jack up the price by 100% and people would still buy them? Even if that's true (it's almost certainly not) the barriers to entry in the video game business are extremely low, so this would just create an enormous opportunity and pissed off consumers would jump to a newly created platform.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by johnnyanmac on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:21PM (#36696990)
>Will the courts allow Microsoft to buy Sony gaming business?

The gaming business, sure. The rest of Sony is still HQ'd in Japan and in fact manages many semi-needed and needed busineses, so there's zero chance MS buys Sony as a whole.

>Microsoft is also getting ready to eat Steam’s lunch for a while on the PC side

Didn't go too well last decade. Best of luck this time.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by bart_spoon on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:29PM (#36703089)
Microsoft is neither close to eating Steams lunch nor is this acquisition going to change anything about the competitive landscape. Microsoft is currently a distant third place behind Sony and Nintendo, and after this acquisition they are... still a distant third.

If Microsoft is ever in a position where a single merger will materially threaten to catapult them over Sony or Nintendo, then that would be the time to block the deal. In the meantime, I would prefer if the FTC doesn't kill off deals because someday, in the far distant future, the companies involved may be in a more dominant position.

If anything, blocking this deal does nothing but protect Sony's already dominant position from one of their sole competitors making up even a small amount of ground.

Re:Microsoft wins FTC fight to buy Activision Blizzard by failuser on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @08:52PM (#36689146)
Games are bigger than most movies. Besides, gaming was responsible for a lot of innovation in computing, we all know how well that will go under a Microsoft monopoly.