> Note: When will a corporation become big enough that we concede that without the monopoly on force and detention it is a de-facto government? At that point can the libertarians give up the 'hands off corporate affairs' schtick
There is absolutely no BigTech company that I can’t use my own free will not to use.
My ad blocker blocks analytics on mobile and desktop that takes care of Google and Facebook.
Whose left?
Also, the cell phone in your pocket broadcasts your location a few times a second, and the corporations with that data love working with the government.
Did they come in your home and force you to use their products?
Let's some questions which don't lead immediately to your 'thought-terminating cliche':
What does having a monolith contribute to society both in terms of value and innovation?
Are there examples where this ended up being beneficial?
Is it a good idea to allow the logical conclusion of free market capitalism be one monopolistic entity which has stifled or bought all competition? What do you think there is to gain by doing such a thing?
So you can’t come up with an example…
> What does having a monolith contribute to society both in terms of value and innovation?
Which BigTech company is a “monolith” without competition?
Every single homeless person that I see out there, has a smartphone.
They don’t have a place to sleep, but they have a phone.
People like to assume that governments and corporations are inherently incompatible, but that’s just not true. A government is just whichever organization(s) has the most power within a geographical region and a company can very easily become the de facto government in an area if its power is unchecked.
For the most prominent historical example of this look at the East India Government: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_India_Company
From a contemporary perspective there are plenty of examples of large multinationals effectively controlling and directing smaller, less wealthy governments. Even in big countries with strong governments, the influence of large corporations on what laws get passed and how they are enforced can become significant.
They already have a monopoly on use of physical force and detention. There is no 'more power' to give them.
You are confusing 'enacting legislation' with 'giving power'. And anti-trust regulation would cover anti-competitive behavior (if we ever enforced it), so no legislation has to be enacted. It is only a matter of determining if it anti-competitive, which it appears not to be.
Rest easy, there are more impactful things to worry about than government overreach into the practices of huge society-shaping entities which are larger than most other nation's governments.
Note: When will a corporation become big enough that we concede that without the monopoly on force and detention it is a de-facto government? At that point can the libertarians give up the 'hands off corporate affairs' schtick?