News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by Y_Y on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:58AM (#36664117)
> "By installing, copying or otherwise using ... you agree to be bound by ... "

Why do people keep writing shit like this. Whoever wrote that EULA no doubt has an understanding of contract law and knows that you can't just unilaterally bind someone into an agreement like that. I know it's classic EULA nonsense, but it still bugs me how you can just write whatever and hope people naively take your word on it.

Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by delusional on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:23AM (#36664282)
It should be disbarrable to knowingly write unenforceable EULA's.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by meghan_rain on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:32AM (#36664347)
The you will surely agree to be permanently barred from looking at, commenting, writing or otherwise contributing to code if you write a bug I deem severe enough?
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by v3d2 on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:35AM (#36664390)
I wasn't aware you needed a license to code.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by kaliqt on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:53AM (#36664536)
With the way peasa- I mean citizens talk these days, they'd say breathing should require a license.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by beepbooptheory on Monday July 10, 2023 @09:34AM (#36666195)
Is this like a feudalism joke? I don't get it.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by dooglius on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:01AM (#36664615)
Seems reasonable to bar someone from contributing code to a project who _knowingly_ contributes severely buggy code
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by DannyBee on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:11AM (#36664715)
This one is likely enforceable.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by imtringued on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:32AM (#36667902)
There is a difference between individual clauses being invalidated and the whole contract being invalidated.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by Zephyo_ on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:27AM (#36664321)
I am very uneducated on this subject, what exactly is the problem with that sentence?
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by t0mas88 on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:35AM (#36664379)
Apparently the code is Apache licensed, so you can use that code.

Putting a file somewhere that states "you agree to X by using the software" without you signing anything isn't an enforceable contract. If they want you to agree to something it needs to be (e-)signed. Not just stating an action and claiming that by doing that you agree to a contract.

Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by DannyBee on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:05AM (#36664651)
Actually, this is totally wrong, at least in the US.

They can't bind you for doing nothing (opening a package for example).

They can bind you if you get the benefit of the bargain, which you would by using the software.

Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by delfinom on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:26AM (#36664847)
There was a Samsung court case in recent times they lost over this btw. They argued users were bound to arbitration due to the EULA piece of paper in the box. The court ruled against Samsung because Samsung could not reasonably prove a user read this piece of paper in a box even though they were using the phone that was packaged. The court explained the Samsung phones would have to prompt the EULA to have active acceptance.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by DannyBee on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:39AM (#36667133)
Not quite - that was because it was labeled a warranty brochure. There are also weird warranty vs contract issues there.

The court, on the contract issue, found that people would not expect to find an arbitration restriction in the warranty brochure, and without something else pointing them at it, it wasn't good enough.

"Here, Samsung entitled the brochure “Product Safety & Warranty Information.” The title would not put a reasonable person on notice that the brochure contained “a freestanding obligation outside the scope of the warranty.” "

The court would have been satisfied if they had put a big ole sticker on the phone screen that said "the warranty brochure contains important arbitration restrictions, you should read it".

No active acceptance necessary ;)

The court was also clear that in-box unilateral contracts are okay under california law.

In this case, you are right the question will be whether someone would be expected to notice it exists.

Unlike a random warranty brochure containing arbitration provisions, EULA.txt and friends are common in software, so a court is likely to find the terms would be there. Of course, if they lose they'll clickwrap it and win.

Don't get me wrong, i think in-box contracts are nonsense, but my personal view is not the law, or even close to it.

Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by rollcat on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:38AM (#36667993)
I was just wondering, if I were to fork the code, remove the EULA, and use that fork as usual - I would not be violating the terms of the Apache license, right?
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by gmerc on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:32AM (#36664360)
What OP says, it’s not enforceable. that’s not how contracts work despite longstanding attempts to make people believe so
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by DannyBee on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:08AM (#36664683)
OP is wrong. This would be a enforceable in the US, despite lots of HN not wanting it to be, and badly playing lawyer.

Unilateral form contracts are enforced all the time.

Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by alphager on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:33AM (#36664362)
A contract requires mutual assent. Hiding an EULA.txt file somewhere does not fulfill the assent requirement. You are already copying nextcloud when you download it; you can't be bound to arbitrary demands you never heard of for that.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by DannyBee on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:09AM (#36664700)
Unilateral form contracts are a thing.

Clickwrap is generally enforceable.

Browserwrap generally is not.

Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by matheusmoreira on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:47AM (#36664487)
Could have been worse. It could have been "by reading this license, you agree to its terms" which is essentially what website EULAs do.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by deng on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:54AM (#36664559)
Unfortunately, it is not that easy. First off, "contract law", apart from being incredibly complex, is also different depending on where you are located. Even within the US, we have seen different rulings on whether EULAs are enforceable or not. It often depends on how these EULAs are presented to the user and how exactly they are worded. Here in Germany, I'm pretty sure that the above would not be enforceable, but the real reason these EULAs are written is usually not that they hold up in court. From my experience, having an EULA like this will make pretty sure that no company with a legal department will touch this thing with a 10foot pole, so in effect, EULAs actually do work (unfortunately).
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by Semaphor on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:18AM (#36664777)
> Here in Germany

I agree, because of AGB-law, though that depends on some stuff, the usual EULA-void rules were because you had to buy the software before agreeing to the EULA instead of the other way around. Not sure what would happen here.

But IIRC that is generally not relevant for contracts between companies, only between consumers and companies. Not quite sure about that part, though.

Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by imtringued on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:27AM (#36667822)
https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__310.html

>(1) § 305 Absatz 2 und 3, § 308 Nummer 1, 2 bis 9 und § 309 finden keine Anwendung auf Allgemeine Geschäftsbedingungen, die gegenüber einem Unternehmer, einer juristischen Person des öffentlichen Rechts oder einem öffentlich-rechtlichen Sondervermögen verwendet werden.

§ 308 and § 309 are "catalogues" of various conditions that nullify an AGB clause. Also, contract clauses in individual contracts can still be considered as part of the AGB even if the company gives you a separate AGB document.

Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by jxdxbx on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:05AM (#36664663)
A “license” is legal permission to do something that would otherwise be illegal, such as copy software (assuming there’s no fair use etc), or even attend a concert. Licenses are often granted as part of contracts, but need not be. Unilateral license conditions are not binding contacts, but not following them can still be unlawful. If a movie theater breaks a license term by for example playing a movie publicly without authorization, it violates copyright, not contact law. Probably both in real life.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by chaosite on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:52AM (#36665055)
Unless that movie theater entered into a contract with a distributor, right?
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by jxdxbx on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:20AM (#36665285)
In real situations yes. But in the software world “license” and “contract” are often used interchangeably, contracts that grant license will be called “licenses,” etc. So it leads to confusion.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by paulnpace on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:41AM (#36665488)
This is a license agreement, so who are the parties coming to agreement?
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by eli on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:11AM (#36666721)
If you're not a party to the agreement then isn't possessing the software a copyright violation?
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by ndsipa_pomu on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:22AM (#36666888)
Only if you are distributing it or making a copy. As to how you came into possession of the software without making a copy is another question.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by tesseract on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:37AM (#36667110)
For binary software licenses, historically a lot of them have been premised on the idea that it is impossible to use the software without copying it from installation media onto local storage and/or from storage into RAM for execution, meaning that effectively it's possible to use contracts based in copyright law to set terms for the use of the software and not just for what a human might think of as "copying".
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by ndsipa_pomu on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:42AM (#36668047)
I recall that being an argument used against piracy, but I don't know if it was successful or not. It seems disingenuous to me as you could classify almost any process to be "copying" e.g. reading a book is using light to make a "copy" of the printed words onto your retinas.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by rightbyte on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:53PM (#36669105)
You could use someone else's computer or maybe you have bought one 2nd handand never agreed to any EULA.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by ndsipa_pomu on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:08PM (#36669345)
Well that would be unlicensed usage of the software, but not copyright infringement by yourself. Resale of software is a trickier topic which may be covered by consumer rights.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by josephcsible on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:15AM (#36666786)
If I buy a used computer, do I have to agree to the terms of every publisher with software on it to not break copyright law?
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by ndsipa_pomu on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:20AM (#36666865)
As you're neither redistributing it or copying it, copyright law is not applicable.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by JohnFen on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:09PM (#36672246)
Not necessarily. Distributing such software would be, though.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by paulnpace on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:32PM (#36676116)
In the context of this EULA, the software can be downloaded from GitHub without any agreement (between user and GitHub).
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by tssva on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:20AM (#36664793)
The blanket statement that EULAs are unenforceable is not accurate. EULAs are enforceable in some jurisdictions. They are where I live.
Re:OwnCloud Infinite Scale added EULA that prohibits commerc... by tptacek on Monday July 10, 2023 @09:47PM (#36675516)
A lawyer downthread says you're wrong about this. Are you also a lawyer? Or are they wrong?