Putting a file somewhere that states "you agree to X by using the software" without you signing anything isn't an enforceable contract. If they want you to agree to something it needs to be (e-)signed. Not just stating an action and claiming that by doing that you agree to a contract.
They can't bind you for doing nothing (opening a package for example).
They can bind you if you get the benefit of the bargain, which you would by using the software.
The court, on the contract issue, found that people would not expect to find an arbitration restriction in the warranty brochure, and without something else pointing them at it, it wasn't good enough.
"Here, Samsung entitled the brochure “Product Safety & Warranty Information.” The title would not put a reasonable person on notice that the brochure contained “a freestanding obligation outside the scope of the warranty.” "
The court would have been satisfied if they had put a big ole sticker on the phone screen that said "the warranty brochure contains important arbitration restrictions, you should read it".
No active acceptance necessary ;)
The court was also clear that in-box unilateral contracts are okay under california law.
In this case, you are right the question will be whether someone would be expected to notice it exists.
Unlike a random warranty brochure containing arbitration provisions, EULA.txt and friends are common in software, so a court is likely to find the terms would be there. Of course, if they lose they'll clickwrap it and win.
Don't get me wrong, i think in-box contracts are nonsense, but my personal view is not the law, or even close to it.
Unilateral form contracts are enforced all the time.
Clickwrap is generally enforceable.
Browserwrap generally is not.
I agree, because of AGB-law, though that depends on some stuff, the usual EULA-void rules were because you had to buy the software before agreeing to the EULA instead of the other way around. Not sure what would happen here.
But IIRC that is generally not relevant for contracts between companies, only between consumers and companies. Not quite sure about that part, though.
>(1) § 305 Absatz 2 und 3, § 308 Nummer 1, 2 bis 9 und § 309 finden keine Anwendung auf Allgemeine Geschäftsbedingungen, die gegenüber einem Unternehmer, einer juristischen Person des öffentlichen Rechts oder einem öffentlich-rechtlichen Sondervermögen verwendet werden.
§ 308 and § 309 are "catalogues" of various conditions that nullify an AGB clause. Also, contract clauses in individual contracts can still be considered as part of the AGB even if the company gives you a separate AGB document.
Why do people keep writing shit like this. Whoever wrote that EULA no doubt has an understanding of contract law and knows that you can't just unilaterally bind someone into an agreement like that. I know it's classic EULA nonsense, but it still bugs me how you can just write whatever and hope people naively take your word on it.