News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Polynomial Functors: A Mathematical Theory of Interaction... by synetic on Sunday July 09, 2023 @10:04PM (#36661177)
I get the complaint. In the old days people would sometimes say “abstract nonsense” when talking about category theory related topics. It’s increasingly an important part of a basic mathematical education at the graduate level. Eventually there may be a spillover into other areas like computer science where so called practical uses occur. But maybe not. It’s still too early to say.

There’s a famous book called Categories for the Working Mathematician. Maybe someday there will be a book called Categories for the Working Programmer.

I like that you call it the string theory of math. It’s a more modern way of saying “abstract nonsense”.

Re:Polynomial Functors: A Mathematical Theory of Interaction... by consilient on Sunday July 09, 2023 @10:38PM (#36661406)
> I like that you call it the string theory of math. It’s a more modern way of saying “abstract nonsense”.

The sociological analogy is a decent one - they're both ambitious sub-sub-fields of little interest to the average practitioner, with a handful of committed opponents and a wildly overgrown internet hatedom - but their positions in their respective disciplines aren't remotely similar.

String theory is a physical theory like any other: pick a spacetime, fill it with dynamical objects, impose some symmetries, and away you go. Category theory, at its most ambitious, wants to be a setting for doing ordinary mathematics in: it belongs in the same general grouping as set theory and higher order logic, not calculus or linear algebra.

Re:Polynomial Functors: A Mathematical Theory of Interaction... by dkjaudyeqooe on Sunday July 09, 2023 @11:13PM (#36661625)