News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by marginalia_nu on Sunday July 09, 2023 @03:27PM (#36657983)
Hmm, I have flagged like 15-20 submissions, maybe 3 intentionally... A confirm dialog may help.
Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by codetrotter on Sunday July 09, 2023 @03:39PM (#36658085)
I intentionally flag posts sometimes.

I think a free-form text input for reason would be nice. No one even has to read the reason most of the time.

Providing a reason for flagging serves multiple purposes:

- makes it so that you don’t accidentally flag something when you don’t mean to

- discourages overly aggressive flagging

- in some cases the reason for flagging might be more subtle. So casual review of flagged posts by mods might miss the subtle reason it is being flagged by people. If we explicitly state the reason, it can help mods see why a post is being flagged by people in such situations

Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by redbell on Sunday July 09, 2023 @07:04PM (#36659981)
> discourages overly aggressive flagging

I recently posted a tweet from pg [0] and as it starts getting some momentum, suddenly got flagged by someone who believes it is paywalled because Twitter rolled out the must-be-logged-to-view feature. It got unfairly flagged despite I provided the full tweet as a comment.

_______________

0. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36563683

Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by tredre3 on Sunday July 09, 2023 @07:44PM (#36660267)
> It got unfairly flagged despite I provided the full tweet as a comment.

Is it really unfair? Your link isn't accessible to a non-insignificant portion of the HN audience, therefore it seems reasonable to flag it.

It isn't reasonable to expect/force people to read comments before flagging content for being inaccessible.

Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by halfdan on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:02AM (#36664138)
I think you misread the latter part of the sentence - OP said they provided the raw text in a comment. This is no different than some other paywalled articles posted here where the first comment usually just links to the web archive for a non-paywalled version.
Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by plorkyeran on Sunday July 09, 2023 @10:36PM (#36661395)
It may also have been flagged simply because pg tweeting yet again about Musk is one of the least interesting submissions possible.
Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by matsemann on Sunday July 09, 2023 @03:59PM (#36658270)
My 9-10 pages of flagged comments seem mostly good, almost all of them are dead and things I think I intentionally flagged.

My 3 pages of flagged submissions seems a bit more random. Perhaps I don't remember the reason just skimming through, but some of them are certainly accidental.

Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by sshine on Sunday July 09, 2023 @05:11PM (#36658940)
I had 4 out of 4 accidental flagged submissions.
Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by kelnos on Sunday July 09, 2023 @06:48PM (#36659836)
My list of flagged submissions is more or less like yours. I think the reason is that I flag things that I don't want to see on HN (not just that I don't care about them, but that I think some topics or specific articles are harmful/toxic to a community), which is often contrary to what many other HN readers think. There's no downvote button on submissions, so there's no other way for me to give that signal.

For comments, I usually only flag when people are egregiously violating site guidelines or are just being dicks in general, and I think most other potential flaggers often agree with my flags in those cases, and pile on. If I just think that a comment doesn't add anything substantive, I'll merely downvote.

I'll also downvote if I strongly disagree with someone's position, after reading an older post on HN from pg saying that's an accepted use for downvotes[0]. I'm still somewhat torn on this, as I'm not sure a nearly 15-year-old post on policy (from someone who seems not to be much involved with HN these days) should still be considered authoritative, as community norms change over time. I also don't love that using downvotes to express disagreement also has the effect of hiding contrary opinions, which can often hold a lot of value. So I try to reserve my disagreement downvotes for cases where I believe I have evidence the poster is objectively wrong about what they're saying.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=658691

Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by maxerickson on Sunday July 09, 2023 @07:09PM (#36660021)
One thing that is hard with submissions is duplicates. Reasonable to flag, hard to identify later.
Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by xoa on Sunday July 09, 2023 @04:00PM (#36658291)
>A confirm dialog may help.

I'm not really a fan of dialogs in flow if it can be avoided, at least not without trying other indicators first, but I would agree some UX experimentation might be worthwhile. Like rather then have it simply go to "unflag", a two letter difference purely in gray, also have it turn bold/bright red for an hour? At least as an option? I just tried playing with the CSS and flagging/unflagging your post, and setting [unflag] to color:red;font-weight:bold makes a real difference without being obnoxious.

Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by kelnos on Sunday July 09, 2023 @06:37PM (#36659715)
Another option would be to add more statuses. When a comment gets enough flags, it gets "[flagged]" added to the top of it. Perhaps something like "[you flagged]" could help.
Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by nmstoker on Sunday July 09, 2023 @06:56PM (#36659907)
I suppose you could change further aspects of the current behaviour, but the issue with that idea is that the flagged items disappear currently, so you wouldn't get to see the "[you flagged]" entry, unless you got to the comments page for it via some other means (eg jumping to it from your browser history)
Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by kelnos on Sunday July 09, 2023 @07:04PM (#36659971)
Ah, good call. I have "showdead" enabled, so I see flagged/dead entries, and didn't think of this. (I do actually often enough find dead comments that IMO deserve to be seen, and vouch for them.)

When you flag something, does it disappear immediately, or only if it's received enough flags to be killed? If the latter, then I think this is much less of a problem. Sure, you may have flagged it by accident, but if it was only one flag away from being killed, it'd probably end up getting intentionally flagged again by someone else soon enough.

Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by nmstoker on Sunday July 09, 2023 @07:22PM (#36660128)
Sorry, I may have got this wrong!

I honestly thought they got removed but it looks like this isn't happening for me (at least not right away), unless it's the scenario you mention where it's only one away from being killed. I think I must have been conflating the behaviour for hide with flag.

Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by marginalia_nu on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:48AM (#36664492)
I think destructive/high-consequence flows is the one case where dialogs are prudent. Dialogs add a lot of friction and extra actions, but that is sometimes a good thing (nobody ever complained about a poolside not being slippery enough).

There's a reason why the emergency services requires you to enter three digits when dialing. Sure it would be a smoother flow if you only had to press a single button or dial '9', but you'd also get a lot more butt dials.

Re:Ask HN: When were flagged submissions/comments added to t... by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 09, 2023 @04:07PM (#36658359)
I would like the ability to disable flagging for my account. Too easy to accidentally flag when scrolling. Or perhaps only offer flagging when you’re on a thread or viewing an individual comment.