News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Super Drug by cs702 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:34AM (#36645378)
FYI, robocat added his note about selection bias as an edit, AFTER I had posted my response.

With the new edits, robocat's comment now make sense to me.

That said, there's still a big caveat: We should look at the change in income for students drawn from the low-income population.

And please follow the guidelines: There's no need to lob insults.

Re:Super Drug by dudeinjapan on Saturday July 08, 2023 @01:47PM (#36646785)
> We should look at the change in income for students drawn from the low-income population

You'd really have to compare outcomes among a population of low-income students who equally "could have gone to Harvard" but some of them didn't for whatever reason. And even here there's a hazard of selection bias--as one example, a "reason" for not going to Harvard might be teenage pregnancy, which is certainly going to put a dent in economic outcome.

If you compare low income students in the top 5% of their HS class who went to state school vs. Harvard I'll bet the gap is smaller still. For example, here's a list of where Fortune 500 CEOs went to college--it's mostly state schools. Warren Buffett went to U. of Nebraska, Tim Cook to Auburn, Larry Page to U. Michigan, etc. https://twitter.com/daveckang/status/1667946905966637061

Re:Super Drug by robocat on Saturday July 08, 2023 @03:34PM (#36647926)
I had to add Selection bias afterwards, because I had thought it was bleeding obvious but user li_am made a snarky remark so I made the comment clearer.: I just don’t understand how you and li_am could totally miss the point, The 98% pass rate shows it so clearly. Note: I am not from the USA but I know this shit.