Re:Hacked: commit to rails master on GitHub
by BenjaminCoe on Sunday March 04, 2012 @03:45PM
(#3663919)
I think you're winning me over to Egor's actions being more irresponsible and misguided than malicious -- chalk it up to him being 18.
I'm finding it pretty hard to stay mad at someone with this tattoo:
Re:Hacked: commit to rails master on GitHub
by alexbell on Sunday March 04, 2012 @05:45PM
(#3664403)
Agreed. Immature - certainly. I don't think his actions were done with malicious intent. Maybe insolent, but that only counts in the military. If he wanted to he could have made his point in a far more malicious manner.
And the octocat tattoo... How can you not like a guy with an octocat tattoo!
I already agreed that GitHub were innocent bystanders and that the timing was unfortunate. But if getting publicity to the issue was the main point, it's also easy to see why GitHub was the perfect target. I also already explained why it could make perfect sense to demonstrate the vulnerability in a public manner rather than just disclose it to one of the many sites suffering from the problem. None of that is a sign of malice, it's at most bad judgement.
The ticket having been opened only three days ago would be a good point if it hadn't also been closed and declared to be working as intended with a pointer to a previously closed bug about the same issue.