Re:Nearly half of the tap water in the US is contaminated wi...
by PartiallyTyped on Thursday July 06, 2023 @02:03PM
(#36620206)
Are UK and Canada that different of cohorts?
Re:Nearly half of the tap water in the US is contaminated wi...
by autoexec on Thursday July 06, 2023 @06:13PM
(#36623907)
At least one study did make an effort to take things like income and other exposures into account. https://www.cnn.com/2019/08/19/health/fluoride-neurotoxin-ca...
At this point I think fluoride falls firmly into the category of "needs more research", but if you're pregnant it seems like actively trying to reduce your intake of fluoride is a sensible precaution since that's unlikely to have any negative effect on you or the kid, but if fluoride does cause problems you could dodge a bullet before the science catches up.
Ecological comparisons are towards the bottom of the evidence hierarchy because there are any number of cofounders at play.
For example you could accidentally conclude that smoking is healthy because smoking tracks with affluence in poorer countries.
So I would reject the notion that we should or shouldn’t see IQ differences in very different populations which is why you want to do controlled research on different cohorts in the same population.
Finally, a causal mechanism is only a cherry on top but it’s not necessary for strong causal inference. Our mechanistic explanations are repeatedly wrong and/or inexhaustive. Fortunately, we can perform good quality studies instead like mendelian randomization.