Honestly I actually don't like the "tax the rich to make them pay their fair share" narrative either because it implies that taxes are what pays for the social programs, which is reductive at best (at least with current US monetary theory). I don't make more than $400,000/year [1], but I have traditionally done pretty well in total comp, and I still vote left because I my viewpoints don't change just because some people were to demonize me.
Also, wasn't Elizabeth Warren's "pay their fair share" tax for people making like more than $10 million?
[1] I actually make $0/year right now due to layoffs.
They simply prioritize their well-being and not being vilified over the social causes you view as $very_important; and I’d suggest that since you bring up issues such as minority rights, you examine why you think they should accept being othered and vilified, when clearly you object to that behavior in other contexts.
Why is that particular example of social abuse something they need to “sit down and shut up” about?
You didn’t explicitly say that because you know your own behavior is inappropriate — and pretend to condemn it in other contexts.
But Democrats are commonly hypocritical — eg, claiming to protect minority rights while being frothing mad they’re told they can’t use 1950s arguments about “too many Asians and Jews” to engage in systemic racism at universities.
I've personally always hated when certain groups are "not allowed" to have an opinion on given topics, for whatever reason, and I have pretty actively said as much when people have told others to "sit down and shut up", so in your particular case you're responding to a straw man and assigning attributes to me that are not true.
EDIT:
You edited your response after the fact and didn't disclose that. I'm responding to your edits now.
> You didn’t explicitly say that because you know your own behavior is inappropriate — and pretend to condemn it in other contexts.
Do I know my own behavior is inappropriate? What behavior is that exactly?
> But Democrats are commonly hypocritical — eg, claiming to protect minority rights while being frothing mad they’re told they can’t use 1950s arguments about “too many Asians and Jews” to engage in systemic racism at universities.
I have very mixed feelings in regards to the way that universities do their recruiting, and even in regards to the recent supreme court decision. Again, you're assigning labels to me that don't really apply. I tend to vote left, so I guess it's fair to lump me in with Democrats in a consequentialist sense.
I think perhaps the reason you had that thought of writing it explicitly was because it was the mentality behind your entire comment.
Ie, it was what you wanted to write; but you knew that was wrong, so you made a bad faith personal attack instead. (The one I called out.)
But the purpose of that bad faith reply is to shame them into sitting down and shutting up about being othered and vilified.
Edit:
> I tend to vote left, so I guess it's fair to lump me in with Democrats in a consequentialist sense.
I’m applying your standard:
You support institutional Asian hate in the same sense that the person you replied to supports the things you accused them of supporting.
If you don’t think you support institutional Asian hate by voting for Democrats, why would you make the accusations you did?
What is the motivation?
I also didn't make "accusations", I said that I thought it was bizarre that someone would change their political positions just because someone was mean to them. I stand by that...I think that's a weird thing to do. If Bernie Sanders personally sent me a message saying "Tombert is a real douchebag", I'm not going to suddenly start going to MAGA rallies, because my political opinions aren't about people liking me.
The inference they changed their opinion on those topics, rather than prioritized something else (eg, not being vilified) is a bad faith inference directly contradicted by their post, which explains why they changed their vote explicitly.
If I were to use your logic, then I’d conclude that you are personally racist towards Asians — because you vote for a party that is. But that would both be incorrect and an act of bad faith.
Elizabeth Warren is not talking about you. Actual rich people are laughing all the way to the bank at people like you for voting for policies for which they will get 99% of the benefit.
Also, "the Democrats" != Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders
The US and EU country GDP's per capita are very similar like around €60k. The inequality is what is different. $400k is just insane in European country.
But your money is still small fry, billionaires own like 30% of everything in the US. Politicians are probably hiding behind taxing your class, rather than the real issue, billionaires.
You write: > As someone who [...] worked their ass off to become a 1%er [...] I worked and studied when my classmates or coworkers were partying, made good choices, and now I enjoy a nice life because of it.
I, like you, work fairly hard and have become quite well-compensated. What I'd like to point out is that there are probably two categories of folks who are NOT "1%ers". There are those who were "partying" and making poor choices and therefore have a lower income. But there are also those who worked VERY hard but never had the opportunity to be rewarded for that work.
It is easy for me to feel entitled about my distinguished-software-engineer-level income if I think only of the first group, but if I compare myself to the second group I have to remember that many of them never had the chance to go to college, never had the opportunities I had and aren't in any way "undeserving". You probably already know everything I am saying here, but I wanted to share that this perspective is one I keep in mind when making statements so I don't come out sounding unreasonably entitled.
A lot of people seem to think of themselves as self-made, without realizing the number of folks who worked just as hard as they think they did without seeing anywhere near the same success.
Maybe something will happen at some point to make them open their eyes, but I wouldn’t bet on it.
Why do you feel the need to lie about the position of politicians when they are so easily available?
https://elizabethwarren.com/plans/ultra-millionaire-tax
Specifically:
> Zero additional tax on any household with a net worth of less than $50 million (99.9% of American households)
So unless you're sitting on a fat nest egg, Sen. Warren thinks that you are indeed paying your fair share of taxes. I'm sure Sanders and Biden agree. Stop lying.
But now all of a sudden, because I make over $400,000 I "don't pay my fair share of taxes", according to Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden? They can go fuck themselves. Until the Democrats stop vilifying people like me, I'm going to hold my nose and vote anti-Democrat across the board. Everyone that I talk to feel the exact same as me.