I don't get the response either. But I've def seen HN folks react without any sort of logic to things so maybe this is one of those times...?
> No competitor could ask for a better time to launch with Twitter and Reddit users disaffected.
I immediately noticed it's branded with Instagram and not Facebook which I think is smart. Insta is seen as "for old people" by the gen Z crowd (that's a direct quote from a friend's kid) but not nearly as old as the FB crowd. I suspect that the disaffected Reddit crowd and the Twitter users more likely fit this demographic.
With that said, my god I would be so happy if something overtook Twitter. As much as I'm not a fan of Meta, Twitter is on the bottom of my list.
There's already a couple of early warning signs for Threads:
1. Your feed is populated by algorithmically sourced content, not just the posts of the accounts you follow.
2. You can't delete threads without deleting the Instagram account it's coupled with.
I would also argue:
3. You can't make a threads account without signing up to Instagram.
All three are attempts to increase company metrics, but which are clearly user-hostile, and will ultimately backfire.
No competitor could ask for a better time to launch with Twitter and Reddit users disaffected.
FB have the experience, reach, resources and timing to win here. Their biggest problems will be other well-funded attempts, but I can't think of any other blue-chips with the same experience or initial advantages (eg social userbase) to bootstrap with.
I'll be buying some FB shares later.