I don't think this contradicts the parent to your comment. There are cases where a teacher can make 30 copies of a portion of a copyright work for distribution in the classroom, and the comment is about those cases.
False, the comment is not about "a portion" of a work, it's about the whole work. I would certainly agree that an educator could photocopy a few paragraphs of a novel, or a textbook, or anything basically, if that work was 300 pages long, and that educator would be within his rights to distribute it to 30 students. A few paragraphs of a 300-page work is a negligible portion when considering copyright.
My personal examples were very definitely about reproducing the works in their entirety. The blog post was about a page and a half, so with permission, I had no trouble making it a handout. The other documents were of comparable length, and it would not have worked to use excerpts. I really wanted the work in its entirety for my students to understand the topic.
If an educator copied a full page of a one-page handout and distributed it to 30 students, they would definitely be in violation, as that is a reproduction in full, and not fair use at all. Ask any news aggregator site how much of a news article they are allowed to quote. They can't scrape the entire article from a website, they need to selectively quote from it so that it is a minimal portion of the copyrighted work. Percentages matter here. The GP didn't even address that question.
The comment doesn't actually specify whether the "material" is a portion or a whole work. It is perfectly plausible that the comment is about those cases.
It is perfectly plausible that the original comment, in referring to "material" was implying the former, but it made no distinction about the latter, and the devil's in the details, as they say.
The blog post provides this link to section 107 of the US Copyright code: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/107
And, in the text of the statute is the following:
> Notwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright.
The above was also quoted by the blog itself. The actual statute says "the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords ... for purposes such as ... teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use) ... is not an infringement of copyright.".
So the statute explicitly details that the statement by the GP is correct. That making multiple (meaning more than one, 30 being more than one) copies for classroom use for the purpose of teaching is actually "not an infringement of copyright".
> (3) the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and
Now as I said, one page of a 300-page text is not infringing and is definitely fair use. If a teacher makes 30 copies of all 300 pages of a 300-page book, what do you think? Fair use too? Ridiculous.
The whole text of the law applies, not just the bits you are willing to cherry-pick here. Every YouTuber knows that fair use often depends on what percentage of the work has been reproduced.
I disbelieve that this is the case, for copyrighted material; this is not supported by your citations, and that behavior (30 copies in a classroom) seems like a flagrant violation, in fact, and although most teachers wouldn't generally get in trouble with it, most teachers also tend to steer clear of violations like this. A teacher either obtains permission, or uses public domain materials, or finds some other way to convey the information to their students.
In fact I researched this when I was teaching a class, and I wanted to use some copyrighted handouts. I was able to obtain permission from a local blogger to use her article and distribute it to the whole class. In fact, she was very glad that I'd asked. I was less successful in contacting a publishing house overseas and obtaining permission for their stuff. So I didn't copy it.