News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI weights are not open “source” by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:36PM (#36602889)
"Transformative use".

The inputs could be copyrighted and the weights could be copyrighted if creating the weights from the inputs is (legally) regarded as a transformative use. And I think it could reasonably be considered to be transformative - the weights don't look anything like the input data.

Disclaimer: IANAL. So far as I know, no court has ruled on whether this qualifies as a transformative use. I take no position on how the courts will actually rule. I merely say that they could regard this as transformative use. (But see jerf's "creativity" argument for another hurdle that weights must pass to be copyrightable.)

Re:AI weights are not open “source” by numpad0 on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:47PM (#36603088)
Another way to look at it is if a thing reproduced a data subjectively resembling originals and then you used it anyhow, then its non-transformative use, and methods used is just extra details.
Re:AI weights are not open “source” by shagie on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:54PM (#36603199)
Transformative use doesn't necessarily mean copyrightable.

Google's thumbnails are a purely mathematical transformation on images (no copyright themselves), and yet are considered a transformative use.

I believe that trained models are similarly a purely mathematical transformation of {data}, but is transformative in what that can be used for going forward.

"Can" bearing a lot of weight in that sentence.

It's how the human, with agency, uses the model that may be a derivative or copyright infringing use - not the model itself nor necessarily the output.

The output of a generative AI may be similar enough to an existing work that it is derivative of that work. It is possible to construct a prompt that infringes on an existing work even if that work wasn't part of the training data.

For that case, consider you drew a picture. That picture that you just drew isn't part of any training data. I could presumably look at it and describe it with sufficient detail that something similar enough would be generated... and that may be considered a derivative work. The same test could be applied to me describing it to someone on Fiverr with the same outcome.

If I were to publish that work by the generative AI or Fiverr - who would be infringing on copyright? me? or the black box that may be AI or Fiverr that created a picture based on my prompts?