News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who cares about the Ivy League? by alephnerd on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:02AM (#36601397)
I'm not denying that, but you are ignoring the fact that Google would open that booth at a LOT of public schools as well. Just off the top of my head - UC Berkeley, UCLA, Mich, Iowa State, UIUC, UW, UW Madison, UCSB, Oregon State, UMass Amherst, etc.

And honestly, I really don't think you understand how hiring whas changed at a traditional corporation.

For management track roles, these companies (eg. Danaher, Abbvie, P&G, Coca Cola) would hire undergrads from regional schools for management track LDP programs.

Traditionally (aka the 70s and 80s) they would recruit from Ivies only, but that basically ended by the 2000s when they saw they couldn't compete on the package.

Re:Who cares about the Ivy League? by user_named on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:50AM (#36602165)
I don't think it's true that companies disregard the ivies and instead look for leadership recruits at no name schools. Source?
Re:Who cares about the Ivy League? by alephnerd on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:05PM (#36602384)
Not Ivy =/= No Name School

CMC has no reputation out East, but has a massive west coast PE/IB alumni network.

Danaher's GM Development Program (leadership track program) targets Carnegie Mellon

You need to attend an elite university to succeed, but an elite university doesn't have to be an Ivy. Selective public schools like Cal, Mich, UVA, UT Austin, UCLA, etc are feeders as well as Selective Privates like Tufts, UChicago, BYU, CMU, CMC, NYU, USC, etc.

Re:Who cares about the Ivy League? by user_named on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:26PM (#36602728)
CMU is close to am elite school so that goes against the argument
Re:Who cares about the Ivy League? by alephnerd on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:57PM (#36603264)
Yes, but it's not an Ivy, as you mentioned in your comment. Unless you are using Ivy to represent the 50+ top universities in the US which are a mix of public and private schools.
Re:Who cares about the Ivy League? by sheepybloke on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @03:20PM (#36605683)
I was a part of GE Aviation's Leadership Program and they definitely started looking towards especially more local schools towards the end of my program. They found that people who were from more local schools were more likely to stay longer term after the program finished. Most of the people they hired from the larger schools would leave pretty quickly after finishing the program.
Re:Who cares about the Ivy League? by ericmay on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:21PM (#36602652)
Berkely, UCLA, Michigan, Washington, are some of the best universities in the country. They exceed Ivy League schools in some fields and compete across the board. These aren't great examples in this context.

UIUC, Wisconsin (CMU as well for example) have really strong engineering programs and "fit the mold".

UCSB (UCI too for example) and Oregon State are based on the west coast. You can get the kids who didn't get in to Stanford or Cal for one reason or another here. I'm guessing UMass fits this profile as well but for MIT/Harvard/etc.

Iowa State is the only one here that's surprising and I'd be curious to find any sort of info online about Google attending their career fairs. It's probably an experiment on Google's part. They typically do not recruit at these types of universities or the footprint is minimal.

Overall the point isn't "has Google ever sat foot on this campus? I guess they recruit there!!" it is "Google primarily recruits at Ivy League Universities (and of course the top 10 or 20 or so universities including public) and that is their bread and butter so to speak. Are you suggesting that Google recruits Harvard the same way it recruits Iowa State?

You initially said "Google didn't recruit my four friends", but Google still goes to campus in-person and recruits there. Google didn't show up at any of the career fairs for my big public universities in Ohio, though I've interviewed a few times based on my own sheer will and luck.

(just to be clear, I'm not picking on Google specifically and these comments can be applied generally to all the top hedge funds, tech companies, non-profits, etc.)

Re:Who cares about the Ivy League? by alephnerd on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:56PM (#36603236)
It's a non-exhaustive list.

Iowa State has a strong STEM program because of Ames National Lab.

They also have on campus recruiting at UTD, UMinn, Purdue, BYU, ASU, and Stony Brook.

And when did you attend college?

And, to be fair, if it wasn't Ohio State I doubt they would have been there.

> (just to be clear, I'm not picking on Google specifically and these comments can be applied generally to all the top hedge funds, tech companies, non-profits, etc.)

What school you go to does matter, but it's doable for most students to attend a semi-selective program and still have plenty of doors open. Indiana Tech or Wright State aren't one of those and probably won't be.

Re:Who cares about the Ivy League? by ericmay on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @01:32PM (#36603813)
> It's a non-exhaustive list.

It's going to be very hard to convince me that Google puts the same amount of recruiting resources into Iowa State or similar as it does Harvard, MIT, Michigan, etc. It's not a matter of "they went to campus at least once, therefore it's the same thing" which is what you're implying here.

> And when did you attend college?

I went to Ohio University (close to the same enrollment numbers as Iowa State actually) 2012-2015, and then went to Ohio State 2018-2020. I did a fair amount of campus recruiting on behalf of my employer, helped Ohio University some with getting companies on campus, and created a hackathon with a career fair element to it as well.

> Indiana Tech or Wright State aren't one of those and probably won't be.

Yes... which further strengthens my original point.

Re:Who cares about the Ivy League? by cmxch on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @09:28PM (#36609728)
> Indiana Tech or Wright State aren't one of those and probably won't be.

Google won’t pick them up, but the public sector and adjacent industries will, provided a passable background.

Depending where those people land, they may end up somewhere that’s on par with if not better than Google.

That aside, I’d like to know what purpose Indiana Tech and Wright State (and their equivalents) fill according to you wrt careers.