I disagree. It does not have to be perfect, certainly not in the first pass given that right now there is no working solution at all. It just has to cover most of the popular web clients on phones and tablets to cover the small children. With time devices and web agents can iterate through improvements.
In terms of bypassing, teens will bypass it but they can just visit sites that a database would never be enforced on in the first place. Many teens today know a myriad of ways to bypass restrictions for porn, drugs, pirating movies and games but that is a different issue all together. Trying to fix this for teens will just splinter the internet even more and will not accomplish anything.
By requiring any site that has adult or user-generated site to add a header any client or government can verify that header is in place. If not they can be reported and the company fined after the implementation phase / period is over.
The current solution does not even exist. Creating centralized databases will clearly just lead to endless lawsuits and just divides of the internet per state which is nearly impossible to enforce. That only benefits feeding the starving lawyers and VPN providers.
I am not underestimating anyone. If a kid is curious enough and smart enough they can bypass anything just as their older teen peers. I would suggest if a kid is smart enough to know what they want to watch then they can probably handle the content or just go to one of the many sites not using the centralized databases as their older teen peers would. That of course should be a discussion between them and their parents. Maybe Usenet will make a come-back by the demand of clever children.
If a kid is not ready for said content and they still bypass it then it should be on their parent to educate them and/or discipline them as with anything else between a parent and child. If it is leading to problems then social services will sort it out as they would with any other parental issue. People must not accept going down this dystopian route of building a centralized ID and even more censorious technology that could easily be extended to any content, not just adult.
[Edit] I should also point out that most tablet and phone OS's support having child accounts. Child accounts can not install any applications.
You can't shoot down proposed solutions on the basis that they aren't perfect unless you actually have a perfect alternative.
Until these blocks cannot be overcome by typing "free VPN" in to Google, they will remain toothless.
Parents have the keys and vehicles in easy access to the children but by and large it's not a problem.
Interesting that despite actual deaths occuring as a result of this norm (when kids do take the cars and crash), we haven't added a law that that only opens the car on a fingerprint scan or some shit, which is effectively what this is equivalent to.
If DEATH doesn't justify such draconian measures then porn most definitely doesn't
It looks like you refute your own argument here. We don't highly regulate automobile access because it's not an issue. Most kids don't have a desire to steal their parents cars, so why would we regulate that? Many kids do have the desire to access things that may harm their development. So you can see why your analogy is largely nonsensical.
Seriously... You dont know what you're talking about.
The vast majority of auto thefts are children taking the family car unauthorized, including well below the age of a learners permit.
Then the therea the class of theft referenced with Kia Boys... Literally teenagers and preteens stealing cars with USB cables....
Go look at reality first before you try to tell me what it is.
Taking this point even further: you mentioned the consequence of this apparent grave problem is death. How many people actually die every year from the grievous problem? I can’t find any deaths caused by kids stealing their parents cars personally, but I’m sure you’re aware of thousands. You must have some good numbers here as I doubt many deaths go unreported.
Did you even try to look?
First result is literally "Boys, 6 and 3, Crash Parents' Car While Driving to Toy Store".... Do I need to continue or can you use Google yourself?