That's why it's nontrivial to do what we do. The best ideas always look like bad ideas.
A good test for your reaction to a startup idea is "would I have said the same thing about Dropbox when it was first started?" On the face of it, there was nothing revolutionary about Dropbox. There were already dozens of similar things.
There are a lot of domains where the people with least experience tend to have the most definite opinions, but startups are an extreme case of it. I find that as I get more experience with startups, I am extremely reluctant to dismiss ideas that seem unsexy, or crazy, or (my favorite) "toys." In fact, when we use those terms to describe ideas to one another during YC interviews, we usually mean them as compliments.
One day when I was having lunch with Richard Feynman, I mentioned to him that I was planning to start a company to build a parallel computer with a million processors. His reaction was unequivocal, "That is positively the dopiest idea I ever heard." For Richard a crazy idea was an opportunity to either prove it wrong or prove it right. Either way, he was interested. By the end of lunch he had agreed to spend the summer working at the company.
We have some really cool ideas in the pipeline that will be released over the next few months. iPhone repair is just the beginning, not the end.
-AJ Forsythe
I think I met you and your crew a while back (last st. patties?) you were with the girl whose dad founded Intuit I believe... (and your friends who had a wine business)...
Anyway - I think that this is a great business, and I wish you the best. If you are going to be the "Campus Helpdesk" then I am sure big things are in store for you.
Sorry I am not excited - I dont mean that to be a personal slant, I guess I am just old :)
Good Luck! and congrats!
Edit: I am the type that likes to fix my own phone. I have had 15 separate iPhones since the first one launched and I have replaced screens on almost every one of them. I have yet to break my iPhone 4 - but I have replaced them on the original, 3G and 3GS.
As an exercise, try to imagine how big it could get (and what it could morph into) with funding and 5+ years of hard work. Heroku started as a Rails IDE in a browser, by example.
Also, a lot of great companies didn't start with a revolutionary product/feature. They just did what they did REALLY REALLY WELL. Facebook, Amazon, Cisco, Zappos, Dropbox... All entered pretty crowded markets without an obvious differentiator (at first).
From the day they launched publicly (like iCracked did today) they were doing the platform thing: http://techcrunch.com/2008/02/07/heroku-lifts-ruby-on-rails-...
Not arguing with your point, which I agree with, just pointing out a problem with that example.
I also abhor the question "how is this different than x's offering"? A startup doesn't need to be meaningfully differentiated from other startups-- it needs to be meaningfully differentiated from what the existing market is currently using.
I just dont find all that novel, or revolutionary... [...] I don't find this to be particularly interesting [...] just doesn't interest me
I am sure that this could make a lot of (boring) money
I think you've answered your own question. I don't remember YC pledging that every idea they sponsor will be a ground-breaking reinvention of the tech landscape.
On the broadest scale, they want ideas that will be successful and give a good return. "Boring" enterprise software, for example, makes one hell of a lot more money than the latest group photo sharing iPhone app.
I was a Geek Squad Supervisor during college (and worked part-time for a few years after). The guys who wrote all the Geek Squad software and standard practices from the corporate HQ were great. However, over time the store management began to run Geek Squad like just another department.
Sales managers don't know anything about technical service, so eventually we began to focus on new PC customers (upgrades, software installs) instead of the PCs that were in the back waiting on repair. Eventually Geek Squad just became an extension of the PC sales department at most stores.
https://twitter.com/aaronbrethorst/status/175695256233324544...
Sometimes I wonder about the YC investments on things that I just dont find all that novel, or revolutionary...
I mean - I guess its cool because they expanded/franchised out to college campuses or something, but I don't find this to be particularly interesting.
It would seem that they must have sold a grander vision to YC; "We will be the Geek Squad of college campuses, everyone on campus has a machine and a phone!" -- there is a real business there, sure, but I am not very excited about it.
Even coming from a career IT background, commoditizing helpdesk/repair and deploying an army of iTech's to college campuses just doesn't interest me.
I am sure that this could make a lot of (boring) money in the future though, so good for them.