Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ...
by kalkin on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:29PM
(#36580169)
There's definitely an audience for debunking x-risk, but probably not one that attracts institutional funding. Being a tech critic in the mode of Timnit Gebru or Emily Bender will get you media attention, but I doubt it's lucrative. (And empirically the media ecosystem doesn't appear to incentivize being fair-minded enough to persuade a fence-sitter, either.)
Debunking AI x-risk is a weird thing to spend time on. There's really no up-side, and there aren't a bunch of rich people paying for Institutes and Foundations on Non-Breathtaking-Very-Boring-Safety-Research. Also, most of the arguments in favor of x-risk that lawmakers and laypeople find most convincing are unfalsifiable, so it's a bit like arguing against religion in that respect.
I don't think there are any public intellectuals in this space doing it well. I'm not sure what to make of that. For myself, I make the argument for focusing on concrete safety problems from within the agencies and companies that are allocating resources. I'm not gifted TED talker.