News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by not_your_vase on Monday July 03, 2023 @03:51PM (#36577952)
It's important to realize that for banks IT is a cost center. They spend only the absolute minimum for IT, because they don't make money with it. I have learned it the hard way, by working for some of them (thought must admit, not in the US). They only spend the absolute minimum on anything IT related - if most customers don't complain about it, and auditors are happy, then it means that it is just perfect.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by jqpabc123 on Monday July 03, 2023 @04:12PM (#36578150)
It's important to realize that for banks IT is a cost center.

Sorry, that argument doesn't float.

TOTP is easy to implement, more secure and costs less to operate than SMS verification --- which is widely supported by banks and in many cases is really nothing more than TOTP codes transmitted across the cell network.

If cost was really the issue, TOTP would likely be the universal default option.

Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by verdverm on Monday July 03, 2023 @04:03PM (#36578067)
unless it's something like Zelle, where they want to force you to use a mobile app so they can... <insert nefarious conspiracy here>
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by Jtsummers on Monday July 03, 2023 @04:09PM (#36578123)
> ... <insert nefarious conspiracy here>

... retain customers and their money within bank accounts so they can lend it out and make money off of it.

Turns out it's not very nefarious, just normal profit motive. Banks make money with Zelle that they'd lose if you Venmo'd money to your fitness instructor who kept it in their Venmo rather than immediately depositing it into a regular checking account.

Do people actually have nefarious conspiracy theories about Zelle?

Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by verdverm on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @03:43AM (#36583504)
Why can't I use zelle in a browser? I would use it if I could, but they require a mobile app. Why?
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by Jtsummers on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @12:21PM (#36588782)
That's not a technical limitation, that's a choice of your bank (and apparently mine). Critically, though, Zelle is competing with Venmo (in particular) and other mobile-only or primarily-mobile apps. Working within the same environment is "good enough" from the perspective of most banks.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by joezydeco on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @12:03PM (#36588461)
Chase lets you Zelle from the browser.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by verdverm on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @12:55PM (#36589308)
Since when? This is not my experience
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by joezydeco on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @12:55PM (#36589315)
Just logged into my account and it's there. I don't know when it was introduced.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by verdverm on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:03PM (#36594750)
Have you tried to use it?

I know the link is there, but last time it took me to pages where you were instructed to install the app

Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by joezydeco on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:29PM (#36595220)
There's verbiage all over the site about a "new look" so maybe it is rolling out slowly to sections of the customers.

Mine currently looks like this: https://imgur.com/a/iFDVVwl

Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by blimpy on Thursday July 06, 2023 @11:10PM (#36626588)
Capital One does too. I’ve used Zelle through Capital One’s website for years, and have never had the mobile app installed.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by gtirloni on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @05:31AM (#36584239)
> It's important to realize that for banks IT is a cost center

Is this a US phenomenon? Where I live, banks are routinely promoting how they are more modern due to their tech. It's far from a cost center and has been like that for at least 2 decades now.

Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't any US bank use TOTP MFA? by jqpabc123 on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @09:02AM (#36586105)
It's important to realize the time value of money.

"Tech" means faster, easier transfers and processing. This is great for consumers --- but not so great for banks.

Banks make a lot of money from "float" --- the lag time between the initiation of a transaction and it's actual completion. The delay between the point in time where money is withdrawn from the sender's account until it is actually credited to the receiver's account. In many cases, this is a day or more in the US.

Bottom line --- most US banks have billions of dollars just "floating" on their books --- continuously. This is someone else's money that the *bank* can earn free interest on.

"Tech" (aka instant transactions) threatens to eliminate this source of income for banks.