I have a simpler heuristic. I ignore all customer ratings entirely, and refuse to leave any.
Coincidentally, NPS is entirely based on this fact. 8+ is required for a "happy customer". 7 is given a little wiggle room to win them back and under 6 is a lost cause.
Huh, could you give an example of it? I am new to the Netherlands and hadn’t realized this yet.
https://www.overstappen.nl/energie/vergelijken/
Under "Beste energievergelijker"
> Onze klanten beoordelen ons daarom met gemiddeld een 8,6.
If you scroll further, you can see their ratings for other services; none reach even an 8.
Compare that to Nerd Wallet's "Best Life Insurance Companies" (a segment that is nearly identical from all providers if you purchase term life).
https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/insurance/best-life-insur...
5/5 across the board for all parties. I get that it's a "best of" list, but you seriously mean to tell me all of these companies are exactly the same? The rest of Nerd Wallet's top pick lists are the same.
1-5. Ranging from pathetic to inadequate, in any case you didn't pass.
6. Adequate, the minimum needed to pass. A culturally important number as it expresses the "zesjescultuur", a phenomenon where somebody is intentionally doing the absolute bare minimum to not get into trouble.
7. More than adequate.
8. Good. Even if near-perfect, few Dutch people would rate above this number because we don't want you to get all cocky.
9. Excellent. In service, only awarded when you did something completely unexpected or memorable.
10. Perfect, flawless.
This is because 1 is the highest grade (mark) in school, and 5 is failing, as is the even-worse 6.
And even so informed, or accustomed to 1-5 scale used by everyone else, Germans are more likely than Americans to give a 4 instead of a 5 to something that they were happy with, but was not the best they’d ever experienced.
I also get the impression that American grades are like this:
- A is good. You made an effort.
- A [however modified with +/++]: great job!
- C is terrible. You skipped all classes or fell into a coma.
The last AirBnB I rented was a five-star house where the host had installed one of those Nest smoke detectors with the motion-sensing night light directly above the bed. He still got a five-star rating, but I went well out of my way to mention the night light in my review.
There was also a massive foam rubber pad on the mattress that made the first night a rough one... but again, some people who are wrong like those, and again, it was easy enough to remove. Or at least, it would've been if my partner hadn't already been asleep on it when I came to bed. The resulting tossing and turning was what made the motion-sensing night light a problem.
Basically I didn't want to go full Karen on the landlord because everything else about the house was comfortable and thoughtful. I felt that a four-star rating would have been projecting a combination of my personal preferences and comically-bad luck on his other potential renters.
It's a complete farce.
About skewed ratings:
0) there is no objective point of reference, every rating is about the reviewer more than the place.
1) google knows about it. they have weighed rating of some sort so 2/5 rating is not going to kill.
2) people in some cultures can give low rating without explaining what they didn't like. either it is complicated to explain what it is or it may be misinterpreted or not publicly acceptable.
I have a friend who has four restaurants in Tokyo, and I've been several times there. If you keep attention to the restaurant reviews in Google Maps, Japanese people is very hard. They'd go like "The food is great, incredible service, surprising flavors, very good experience, best Spanish food I've had in a long time..." and then they go "...but I know they can do better and have space to improve. 2/5".
In Spain we would be like "Nice beer, they gave us some tapas. 5/5"
Gig economy corporations also have made this worse. You're scared to score your driver, your server or your hotel by less than a 5/5 or somebody might get punished or fired (and maybe they didn't even had a contract in the first place).
And this becomes a snake biting its own tail. Now I rarely go to a place with a score of less than a 4/5, and I'll score relatively high because I know I could influence votes out of what people consider "worthy to visit".